5 stars because they host a legendary pig roast during the summer for their devoted patrons in addition to what they do best every day and night!
This is your archetypal snowmobiler's bar, something my sister and her husband discovered is quite a crowded subcategory of biker/dive bars when you relocate to central NY state. Luckily this one is great and is around the corner from their house. When mom visits the same time I do then the 3 of us (sis, b-i-l, and I) get to all go out together instead of just the b-i-l, who is in love with Amy the bartender (disclaimer, so am I, if she and I happened to be lesbians or bi- then I would want her to be my girlfriend for at least a day.... or even an hour ;)
Solid bar (they carry Makers Mark!), super cheap (especially if you're visiting from San Francisco), great bar food (excellent chicken fingers and fries, tacos are great and cheap, and steamed clams, too!) friendly bartenders (and the owner is on premises a lot) a pool table and darts, and an internet jukebox so I can find obscure 80's punk and pay to have it played before all the country music that others have picked and the same Kid Rock, Metallica and Breaking Benjamin tunes that the b-i-l tries to play every single time he steps into the place!
I get wasted here a lot when I'm on vacation, visiting my family.