Callaway's Pizza & Pasta

I've been dying to try this Italian spot for years and finally made it there. I've always thought that you can't mess up pasta. Noodles and sauce, how hard can it be? I was mistaken.
Callaway's has lost my business for good. The pasta was dry, bland and too salty.
The service was the worst in the valley. Rude service can sometimes be forgiven, but this service was beyond that. The wait staff took entirely too long on just a few of our groups orders. By the time some were completely finished, others received their dishes. The staff was unforgiving.

Would I recommend Callaway's to my friends? No, not even my enemies.

A pearl in the mucus laden oyster of Smithfield.

Our Asain buddy took us to Smithfield to Italian restaurant with an Irish name, how can you get more American than that.
The service was about as friendly as you can get without getting arrested for solicitation. They were very attentive and always willing to be of service. They made sure every time our bread sticks were out they quickly refilled them.

The food was great, we got the molten lava cake as an appetizer. This is the first time I have ever had it with ice cream and whipped cream. On the advice of our buddy we all got the spaghetti with meatballs, veggies, and a side of Italian sausage. All I can say is WOW it was great, and they are not afraid of garlic. The meatballs were small enough to be one bite but large enough to fill even my mouth (and we all know how much I like to have my mouth stuffed with meat). The sauce is not overly rich and it is about as hearty as you can get. It is the warmth of a nation on a plate. The bread sticks are great and always warm. On the 92 mile ride home I was remembering how good that sausage tasted in my mouth.

Although a little out of our way we will be going back. I think next time we will ride our motorcycles. It is a beautiful ride and it wont rain on you.

The best I can say about Callaway's is that the pizza is better than edible. The pasta dishes, on the contrary, are about as salty and tasteless as the Olive Garden on a bad day. And the service is as slack and unprofessional as I've come to expect from Cache Valley restaurants. The last time I was there, the service suddenly became so slow and inattentive after we ordered our alcoholic beverages that we left before ordering our meal. If Callaway's and their staff aren't comfortable selling alcohol, I wish they'd give up their beer and wine license so a more deserving establishment could take better advantage of it...