The wait was not long sitting down, but the service was very slow. The food took a long time too. We went in to get peel and eat shrimp but it wasn't on the menu anymore. We use to go there all the time before they closed. Was upset when we found out they had it and no one told us. The server said we should of asked. I'm a server and that was their job to tell us that they had it. Was very disappointed. But we will try again. We use to love Caseys
Review Source:I came here for dinner on a Saturday night in July. Â I was with a group of four other friends and we did not plan ahead. Â We had no dinner reservations and figured we'd just wander from our hotel (the Marina Grand) into town and see what looked good. Â We went to dinner around 7:45/8 and it was PACKED. Â There was an hour wait here and a longer wait at Brewster's down the street, so, not wanting to walk any more (some of us get cranky when we don't eat in a timely fashion), we decided to wait it out at Casey's. Â
We finally sat down around 9:15 as the band was setting up inside. Â From my understanding, the band was supposed to play outside, but it was raining on and off, so they moved indoors. Â I don't mind live music with my dinner, but the band was SO loud. Â The acoustics for an indoor performance were way off. Â
The food was just so-so, nothing great. Â I definitely would not go out of my way to come back.
HOWEVER, the people-watching when we were there was fantastic, so for the people-watching alone, I might consider going back...
My wife an I ate here for dinner while staying in new buffalo. It wasn't too expensive and the food was pretty good. Service was good too. The bar where we sat was noisy but it still had a nice atmosphere. Some other reviews were somewhat critical but if you are not expecting a 5 star restaurant and just want a good meal in a nice place this place will do the trick.
Review Source:Enjoyed a Guinness on draft - that was good. Ordered a burger w/ blue cheese and a side of fruit. Asker the waiter what the fruit was and he said it had pineapple. Also told him NO PICKLE ANYWHERE ON PLATE. Food arrived and contained 3 pickles and no pineapple. To top it off the pickles were touching 1/2 of my burger and the toppings (lettuce, tomato, onion) and apparently the kitchen staff plucked the non-pineapple containing fruit mix with their pickle soaked hands - as the fruit tasted like it was soaking in pickle juice. Needless to say - I enjoyed the draft beer and was forced to practice portion control as I despise all things pickled.
Review Source:Went here for burgers and drinks. Â The place is nothing fancy, which is fine by me. Â The service was good, but the beer could have been a bit colder. Â The burgers were very good. Â The meal came with soup or salad and fries. Â Lots of food for little money.
Casey's is popular and does get packed. Â Would go back again.
Great food. Great atmosphere.Specials are always tasty. Usually have great music on the weekends. I would give it 5 stars but I can't stand seeing half the staff working their behinds off, while the other half stands around texting or appearing to be busy.
Overall this place rocks. If your in New Buffalo, stop by.
Check my other reviews, I've been to multiple establishments over SW MI for years now.
This is the mainstay, or anchor, bar/restaurant on the New Buffalo strip whether you like it or not, and believe me I don't really like it all that much. Â Bar beats the restaurant, has a quality long wooden bar when you walk in, which I am sure looks real homey/Irish-style to all the FIPS that mob it in the summer. Â Only 2 tvs, mounted up high at the ends make for difficult game watching. Good beer selection. Food quality is a little above Fridays and that's about it. Â Patio, blah blah. It's no wonder the locals get hostile sometimes because you truly get the extreme Illinois a------- coming in here. I once had a Scottish guy from Oak Park go ballistic on me for talking to his wife, OMG, chill the f out you lunatic, we're in a beach town. Â If you want to experience this place for what it really is, and nothing else, come in winter. In fact, that holds true for the majority of southwest Michigan.
bar food nothing new
good beers slow waiter forgot rings
lake perch was ok
I don't really know what is stellar in New Buffalo, but we just came here because lake perch was on the menu, and it was pretty good. Â Yeah, it was alright. Â Go for the perch sandwich and save a buck over the platter. Â They actually had a pretty good beer selection in my opinion. Â
Our waiter was pretty slow (even though he seemed stressed running back and forth) and forgot our onion rings... It didn't seem that busy, but maybe they were short handed. Â
Seemed like an ok place to watch the ND game (boooo) and have a decent beer.
Well, there aren't *that* many places in town to eat, and we already tried the Stray Dog, so we figured we would give this place a try.
We got a great first impression: the maître d' couldn't have been more pleasant; all smiles, and it actually felt sincere.
The food itself was just fine, but nothing that blew us away. We had some wine and pasta dishes. The mussels made for a good appetizer. Nothing memorable, but not bad. I would return because it was good enough, and I enjoy the beach-having area as a whole.
This review is for drinks only....the menu wasn't my mostly vegetarian forte.
Excellent spot for cocktails and music on the outdoor patio (in spite of the mosquitoes that devoured my entire body...beware). Â Lots of locals and out of towners. Great wine selection. Â Fast and friendly service.
Casey's is a bar/restaurant on the strip in New Buffalo. Â I love the long bar itself and the great beers on tap (Bell's included). Â I'd give it five stars as far as the bar goes. Â The restaurant I would say is above average - burgers, steaks, chops and plenty of fishies. Â I do prefer Casey's for the bar experience over the restaurant experience though. Â I found myself in for drinks twice and once for grub the last time I was in New Buffalo.
The clientele at Casey's includes plenty of locals, skewing towards a more mature crowd, as well as weekenders from the city. Â
The last time I was in Casey's for drinks, I got the stink eye from three older yocals at the bar, for whatever reason. Â I suppose they knew I was from the city. Â Maybe they thought I was too pretty? Â Who knows? Â There were no incidents other than a wry smile and a smart ass cough in my column. Â And I had the hot chick anyway. Â Victory. Â Damn tourists. Â
Four stars.
Since this was a great weekend in SW Michigan in all, I wanted to rate this place higher and looked for so many ways to do so but it often came up short.
First off we sat down on a Monday night at 8pm and there were not that many diners around. That said the service was slow. The coffe was cold and when a member of our group ordered a Southern Comfort withe Sweet Vermuth she got a scotch... I explained that to the waiter and he had no problem with that but it appeared the bartender did - I drink scotch so I know what was served.
Our food was fantastic but the Merlot I asked for with my strip steak never showed up. My wife also requested no olives on her meal and yup - there they were.
Now normally I would give this place 2 stars but everyone enjoyed their food and the waiter did come out with a huge slice of chocolate cake - a reprise for the mistakes made earlier - kudos to him.
We'd go back but we'll also try the Stray Dog and Roadhouse before hand.
I was very dissappointed with the quality of food here and the service. Â In their defense, we did have a very large group and it was later in the night, but the back room was VERY loud and it took over an hour for our food to come out. Â I really didn't see anyone's food at the table that looked very good. Â I had oysters, and the flavor and presentation was very nice, but they were not of the best quality. Â The perch tasted good, but not what I expected...I might go back to the bar, but won't visit this place for dinner again.
Review Source:It's fine. Â It's a bar so the food is just that - fine. Â The chili was very good and another in our party said the clam chowder was also good. Â The panini is on a hamburger bun (not really pressed either). Â I didn't hate it but I'll try one of the many other nearby choices before going back here.
Review Source:We went to this old-fasioned restaurant before a rock concert just outside.
Some foods were better than others but overall, the food was fairly decent. My chicken alfredo was one of the decent foods on the menu. What I think is one of the better foods on the menu is the clam chowder.
Everything here was o.k. Nothing was great, and nothing was bad.
Evryone said choose the perch it is the best. Well I wanted the pork chops. They smelled good coming out and I was not disappointed. They were tender and were seasoned just right, i added some sauteed onions and they hit the spot. Everybody else were not as impressed with there choices. Down sides are the service was not to quick and smoking is still allowed.
Review Source:Like the food, the wait/bar staff are chatty and really friendly. Â Love the food and drinks too. Â The interior is a little scruffy and I actually don't care so much as long as the service and food are good, which they are. Â My only complaint is that I went in one night and the place was hazy, due to cigarette smoke.
Note to Manager: Why don't you go smoke-free like the Red Arrow Roadhouse? Â Soe's (in Sawyer) food isn't quite as good as yours, but the interior is nicer and it's not smoky.
Great food. great prices, and superior service.
We hung out at this little local restaurant/ pub for a couple of hours just whiling the day away. Had a few drinks, and some good conversation.
The NY strip steak sandwich seems to be what they're famous for, but they have a very extensive menu that's worth taking a look at.
Great times had by all.
The 5 best restaurants in the 2015 Denver Restaurant Week
3,611 Views | Category: Denver
The complete list of 2015 Denver Restaurant Week businesses
1,971 Views | Category: Denver
The tourists' guide to Portillos: 5 must have dishes
3,316 Views | Category: Chicago
Pho = Pronounced "fuh" not "foe" for pho-king sake
2,913 Views | Category: Denver
Indulgery selected to exhibit at Collision Conference
2,986 Views | Category: Press Releases
Not Logged In
BUSINESSES
Local Businesses
Near Me
My Favorites
SOCIAL
Blog & News
MY ACCOUNT
Login
Register
Contact Us
Add Your Business
