I'm a big fan of Creno's, and I love the New Concord location because the staff is super-friendly. They make it a delight to be a regular. They keep their restaurant neat and clean and really go out of their way to be sure my table is wiped down before I sit and if I mention that it's chilly, they turn up the heat. You can't ask for better service than that!
I love their pizza, I love their subs (especially the Italian and the turkey), and I love their salads (which compare to the great salads you get at Adornetto's in Zanesville), and I loooove their garlic bread (with cheese!)
The only thing I've tried that I wasn't crazy about was the spaghetti - a little overcooked, and the sauce didn't work well.
If you're trying to decide which pizza and sub place to stop at in New Concord, I definitely recommend Creno's!