I was here in the summer of 2008 on a bike ride along the Elroy-Sparta trail. This place was recommended by all the locals.
The food was very good. I had a roast beef sandwich and it was warm and juicy. The topping were all very fresh. The chips were also very good.
As the name of the cafe suggests I had a piece of pie for desert. It was great! the crust was very flaky and the filling had excellent flavor.
The people in the cafe were very friendly. The shop has a great cafe feel to it. They also have a bike rack on the side for all the people who make the stop along the trail.
If you ride the Elroy-Sparta Trail(Highly recommended) or are just in the area, stop by Gina's Pies are Square.
Next time I'm in the area I will be returning for a second helping!