Maggie's Cafe Reviews | New Florence Restaurants & Bars

0

A gritty cigarette smoke filled family restaurant with greasy food. Â Had the folded turkey slab sandwich. Â After reading the reviews, maybe I should have just had the pie.

Review Source:

Posted on 05.18.12 Doug K.

Report

0

I had heard good things about Maggie's so we thought we'd give it a try for supper while we were in New Florence traveling last year. It was pretty good. I had a 3 cheese and mushroom omelet. I'd had better omelets...when I heard it was home cooking I thought the mushrooms would be fresh, but they were canned. It wasn't bad...just not as good as I expected. The omelet came with hasbrowns and toast. My Dad had a huge tenderloin that he loved. I'll put a picture of it on here. He said it was really good. My mom had a hot beef sandwich. She was a little disapointed. She said the mashed potatoes seemed fake and the gravy was pretty bland. My Great Aunt had a breakfast with 2 eggs, toast, and hashbrowns. She said she really liked hers.

Dessert...mom and I got pie. I got chocolate and she had coconut. The marange was piled higher than I've ever seen before. Again I'll add a picture!! It was the best part about the meal for me.

The prices were average and it had a truck stop type atmposphere. Nothing fancy, but it was clean. There is a salad bar option, but we didn't have it.

Overall...Maggie's was okay, but it wasn't the home cooked food I expected from reading other reviews on other websites. 1/2 of us really liked our food the other 1/2 was just okay with our food. Not bad...not great...I think it just all depends on what you order.

Review Source:

Posted on 04.11.11 Samantha L.

Report

0

We saw this Cafe in the "Next Exit" book and stopped for coffee & pie. When we got there, the name had changed to Dad's Cafe (some staff had new t-shirts and others had the old t-shirt)...but...the coffee was really good and the pie's were (1) homemade, (2) fresh, and (3) terrific! Â This is a great stop and we'll go back next trip to try either breakfast, lunch or dinner. Â They were pretty crowded for an off hour, so the locals obviously know and appreciate this spot. Â Give it a try.

Review Source:

Posted on 02.24.11 Jim N.