The Old Marco Pub & Restaurant

We went here based on the reviews on Yelp but found it to be pricey and not worthy of the 4 star average it carries. To start the decor of the restaurant is straight out of the 70s complete with wood paneling, plastic flowers and poor lighting. The placed looked like it has not had a thorough scrubbing in some time particularly the AC vents which were caked with dust. They share the space with a Pub (same owner) divided by a single wall. While I enjoy Aerosmith and AC/DC I do not necessarily want that music coming from the jukebox next door especially when I am having dinner. If you are going to have both businesses make sure the music doesn't start until after dinner (say 8 or 9 PM). My wife and I stuck with the fish and the entree was good but not spectacular. A small green salad drenched in salad dressing and a pasta (ziti) side dish completed the order. Prices range from $18 (salmon special) to $28 for the stuffed grouper. Definitely on the high side for the island. Better options include Snook Inn where the salad bar is more varied and plentiful as well as Arturo's if you are looking for Italian. In short, you will get a decent entree and good service here, I just feel that for the money you can do a better.

Old Marco Pub was a surprise! It is outstanding Italian food. My husband  is Italian and grew up in the restaurant business so he knows good food. The best crab cakes I have ever had and the Osso bucco is amazing. This is a restaurant you do not want to miss.

Decent Italian food but nothing special. Good friendly service. Tried the veal rolitini and Oslo bocco not a lot of flavor. Better at DaVinci's, Arturo's and Sale y Pepe.