Whitey's Peetza & Eatery

Came here with my in-laws, who live in Indiana. I never knew this place existed, though, it has only been 3 years. Had it been open during my stint at iUP I would have been a regular. What a cute, fun place, tucked away (kind of) in the middle of nowhere! First, I ordered the Blairsville blush (wine), mostly because I love sweet wine and I thought that was my best option. I didn't expect much from the great and famous vineyards of Blairsville....but wow wow wow. Where can I buy 10 more bottles? So good!

We ordered (I forget the real name) a fried appetizer that consisted of cheese logs, onion rings, and chicken tenders. The mozzarella logs were meh, though the rest of my table loved them. I wasn't a fan of the breading . The onion rings were pretty good. The chicken was chicken. Moist, but nothing special. We also got the Cajun wings. They were quite good! I have to agree with Paul A. regarding his review of the wings.

For my entree I got a buffalo chicken Pittsburgh salad. I am a firm believer that the fries make or break a Pittsburgh salad, and this salad was fantastic! I mean there isn't much to say about a salad, but the ranch was good, the chicken was good, the buffalo flavor was good, and the fries were great!

Can't wait to return!

Was just here today and was pleased as I've heard lots of good things about the place...awesome outdoor sections...will definitely be returning!

I am Italian-American, my wife is the real McCoy. - Italian born and bred! We LOVE Whitey's. While we stick to the more traditional pizzas, they offer a wide array of toppings.

What's truly amazing about their pizza is the crust. It's perfect, if you are looking for the type of pizza served in Naples. The sauce is wonderful, too, and the mozzarella is what you have to expect if you don't have Neapolitan  Buffala cows to make real mozzarella.

Having grown up between Buffalo, NY, I am very choosy about wings. I am wild about their awesome wings. They rival the Anchor Inn (if you come from Buffalo, you know what a complement that is!). I would stay away from their hottest sauce if you are a traditionalist. They use habaneros, which though VERY hot, have a taste that does not marry well with chicken, IMHO. The wings are really meaty and Cooke perfectly.  They have great salads, if you are looking for lighter fare.

They offer a good selection of beer and have a bar (that's a sight to be seen). There is outdoor eating which is a welcome change from many of the restaurants around here.

This place is worth the trip. Indiana should create a bus service for those unfortunate enough not to have a car to take you to Whitey's.