In for late lunch on 11/19/11. Great decor, simple menu and great service.
We both ordered soup, she French onion and me clam chowder. Our server brought a sample of spinach shrimp soup that was outstanding. Both our soups were excellent and hot. She had the mahimahi taco and I had the Cuba burger. Both were  exactly as described and prepared as requested. Very good and I'm looking forward to returning soon. We did not sample the alcohol but the bar seemed well stocked.
I was somewhat surprised that we were one of only two couples in the grill. C'mon Elkhart. Don't lose this gem without trying it at least once!