Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub & Restaurant

Because I had read so many favorable reviews, perhaps I was expecting this place to be a cut above average. But average it is. Yes, we sat outside and had a nice view, and yes, the pies are good, but otherwise, strictly average and Door County is home to many above average restaurants so there's no reason to settle. The rolls were of the basic food service variety, the seafood chowder had big pieces of fake crab and little flavor in any case (no competition for the Cookery's whitefish chowder, that's for sure). My whitefish sandwich with cajun seasoning was really spicy hot (and I do like spicy food). My husband thought his whitefish with the same seasoning was fine (and for $18, came with three little potatoes and a cup of soup---actually my sandwich with ala carte sides was a better value), so who knows? But the sides were ordinary, service was OK.... as I said, a nice location and view, but the food is not anywhere near as described in the reviews, in my opinion.

This place is fantastic! The food exquisite and service is even more amazing! What a great find. The fish is so superb.

We decided to give it a try based on the recommendations of several locals.  Based on recommendations we tried the Anniversary Burger.  This huge half pound burger does not disappoint  and it comes with a large side of tasty fries.  There is a fair selection of  beer on tap (for $3.25 or 3.50!) also. Service was quick and attentive. We will be back!