Brothers Pizza

As a transplanted New Yorker and unabashed NY pizza snob, Brothers is about as close as you can get to NY pizza, particularly in West Virginia.

This has become my go-to pizza joint. If you are from NY, you've probably had better. But that isn't a knock on Brothers. It's consistently good, very fairly priced, and the owners (rightfully) take pride in their products.

I live less than 1 mile from 3 pizza places, and thy all deliver. 98% of the time, however, I opt to make the 10-mile trek to Brothers. It's worth it.

Rating is for Pizza only (and factors geography into he equation), although their other offerings are all solid "pizza joint" standards.

Food was priced way too high for the lower quality.  First we ordered the calamari to split there was only about 8 pieces on the plate making each ring little over a dollar a piece.  For dinner I ordered a sandwich and at the price of it I feel should come with fries instead of having to pay almost 3 extra dollars for a batch of barely ok generic frozen fries.  Our service was sporadic at best.  Food came out before salads.  We never were offered refills on our drinks.  Two other tables near us walked out after being unable to get service.  I will never go back!

Best pizza outside NYC. Colossal pizza is a deal and easily feeds a family of 7. We are a DC family that vacations in harpers ferry and a weekend isn't complete without a stop at Brothers. Yum!