Cozy Corner Cafe & Tap Room

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  Stopped in for breakfast. What a mistake.  My scrambled eggs were good, but everything else was not.  My husband's eggs, which he requested over easy, came dumped (almost rolled up) on his plate.  His sausage was cooked to the consistency of burnt leather.  The home fries had a very sour taste.  Our cokes were flat, so we swapped them for milk, which was $3 a glass.  We won't be back.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 10.16.13 Pam B.

  • Report
• 0

  Great little spot for lunch, lots of healthy options and VERY reasonably priced. I had the hummus veggie wrap. Delicious!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 09.13.13 Heather W.

  • Report
• 0

  My husband and I stopped in for lunch today - what a pleasant surprise!  A very fresh and clean interior, with walls spotlighting local artistry.  The menu was simple and prepared exceptionally well.  The homemade lemon vinaigrette was a perfect complement to the cobb salad which was made with fresh lettuce, very crispy bacon, homemade turkey breast, etc.  My husband had a BLT on crusty sourdough bread which was beautifully made and a barley soup that was clearly homemade - delicious.
  
  The prices were insanely low.  This is a welcome addition to Amenia and this corner of New York and we look forward to returning for Jazz night!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 08.11.13 Jamaize S.

  • Report
• 0

  A welcome improvement over the Greenleaf Cafe, which was previously in this location.  That version seemed to have meant well, but hired poorly in the kitchen.  The food was indifferent on a good day, and terrible on others.
  
  The newly-revived Cozy Corner has a new menu, which says that they make everything fresh.  We had lunch, a grilled tuna sandwich and the burger.  The grilled tuna was grilled fresh tuna, with a nice wasabi mayonnaise and some mild arugula on a moderate-sized ciabatta, quite tasty, and not overdone.  The burger was good quality beef on a good bun.  The best features were a mustard (on the side) that had a real kick like only freshly-made mustard can, and a delightful house-made pickle.  The pickling was very slightly sweet in the background, and had a spice I couldn't identify for certain, but might have been fresh ginger.  These were very nice touches, and if they're a sign of things to come, then Amenia has gained another quality place to eat with interesting food.
  
  Wish them well - if the trend keeps up, this place will be a big hit.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 06.01.13 Eddie M.

  • Report