Creamery Pizza & Ice Cream

I swear to god, we were the only people in the building who didn't know each other! This is small town America at it's finest. This adorable little pizza joint slash ice-cream parlor is smack-dab in the center of this tiny town that's situated in the middle of a hollar. Everyone who walked in stopped at other tables to talk to other people. Everyone knew each other.

I'd give 3 stars for service, but 5 stars for cuteness/quaintness, so we'll give it an overall 4-star rating. The place seemed to be ran by 15-17 year old girls. I don't think I saw one employee over the age of 17. Odd. The waitress wasn't great, but, she tried. At least she was friendly.

The pizza was pretty good! We're from Chicago where pizza is GREAT - and we were happily surprised by their pizza here. Their thin-crust was on the thick side, sometimes called hand-tossed or double-dough. There was a little too much sauce for my liking, but the load of cheese made up for it.

Aaaaaaand of course since they're also an ice-cream shop, we just HAD to get ice cream. I mean, It'd be rude of us not to, right?!?! I got a waffle cone with oreo ice-cream and it hit the spot. Mmmm mmmm yummy!

There's plenty of seating space - there's a smaller dining area, a larger dining area, and outside seating as well. There's a cute little fireplace they may use in winter. There's also a big buffet thingy in the middle of the room, so they must do buffets at some point.

If you're in the vicinity (or even staying in Rochester for Mayo, but in the mood for a drive) then definitely check this little place out. It's really a cute place.

The giant creamery special pizza can't be beat!  This monster pizza has every topping on the menu, but be sure and ask for sauerkraut and/or jalapenos to up the ante a bit more.  We order one of these to go and have a terrific supper, plus we eat leftover pizza for breakfast, lunch and dinner for at least another day or two.  Yes, pizza for breakfast---it is delicious!!  If we are not staying in Rushford while we are riding the bike trail, we will drive to Rushford just to order this pizza.  We love it...