Fontana's Supper Club

My husband and I have enjoyed - thoroughly - two meals here (months apart).  The first experience was so good (except we did wait a few minutes to be served - but, we enjoyed the cozy atmosphere of the bar).  In fact, we ate in the back of the bar and loved the tasty pasta and the melt-in-your-mouth steak covered in buttery mushrooms.  The first trip happened to be my husband's birthday - they treated him to a special dessert - delicious!  Went back again just a few days ago.  We took our favorite seats at the back of the bar and were immediately waited on!  My hubby had more pasta and I had steak and lobster (also had salad, buttered mushrooms, baked sweet potato and a yummy turtle cheesecake dessert.  So much food (again), we enjoyed our "left-overs" the next night.  We will be going back!!!

I've tried and tried to give this place a chance.  As of my last visit, I will not return.

I went to Fontana's recently with my girlfriend and another couple.  We were provided drinks but our waitress disappeared when it came time to order dinner.  We clearly got the attention of some other servers who ignored us.  We finally went to find her and practically dragged her back to the table to take our orders!  The Italian entrees were clearly sub-standard - thick, tough raviolis and gnocchis with a mediocre red sauce.  This type of service and food has been the norm for this place on most of my visits.

I never root against local, small businesses, but in this case I wouldn't miss them if they closed their doors...

Great food; service lacking.