While the food was fantastic.  Buffalo meatloaf with real mashed potaotes and fresh green beans and greek quesadillas, great beer selection. Here we went there to watch the now infamous Packer game on Monday evening September 24, 2012.  The bar ask us to leave at the begining of the last quarter!!  We were lucky enough to catch another bar nearby that was just closing but let us in for the end of the game.  Seems Issacs closes when there  are no pople left in the dining room.  NFL game or not!!  We went there exclusively to watch the Packer gamewhile on the road.  Tom & June Milwaukee
Review Source:OK, I try not to just toss out 5 star ratings like Halloween candy, but 3 simple words clinched it for Isaac's-- DUCK FAT FRIES. Oh, yeah! Leave your "Eat This, Not That" book in the car, and step in for a serving of the yummiest plate of fries imaginable!
Isaac's is a great little Old West-style saloon/restaurant, in the cute, quaint, funky/quirky/artsy little town of Silver City. As my good friend Melissa Chambers (Of EXIT Horizons Realty, Las Cruces--Let her find just the right home for you! ***She paid for the meal. Will work for food!***) and I dined here, most of the clientele were watching the Green Bay Packers and the Pittsburgh Steelers thwart their final challengers to Super Bowl glory. The was a nice-sized TV at the main bar, and a giant-screen theater-style lounge in the back, filled with fans. Â The entire atmosphere, football-mania aside, was friendly and comfortable.
We had a great waitress; friendly and attentive. The menu was upscale bar fare. Melissa and I were both drawn to the bison burgers; hers with swiss cheese, mine with swiss and sauteed onions and mushrooms. Both were accompanied by the aforementioned duck fat fries. Everything was a delight! The burgers were outstanding, the fries delivered on their promise. It truly was an excellent, even remarkable meal.
I enjoyed Silver City so much, that I plan to visit regularly, and Isaac's will be a frequent stop as well!
We came during a trip to town, and were pleased to find this place.
It was trivia night, but we opted to sit in the quieter bar area. Our server was a little out-of-whack, but the food was overall pretty good. I liked that they had buffalo meat on the menu in several dishes, and their draft beer selection wasn't bad either. Bar food.
For Silver City, I was impressed. I know that the downtown area is trying to grow, and I think this place will aide that effort. It is definitely geared toward a local hangout scene, and that can only be good for foot traffic in other sites.
Went there on Halloween night, which was great. It was the place to be in Silver on Halloween.
Other than that, the place was kind of interesting. The dining room is enormous, and the atmosphere a little odd. Service was good, but totally unorganized. The waitresses seemed to be running around in a panic, nobody knew which table they had to cover.
The food was basic, nothing to brag about. I did like the buffalo nachos, and my rib eye steak was decent.
On my next trip, however, I think I'll try somewhere else in town.
I visited Isaac's on a 8/809 while on vacation in Silver City. Â It was a Saturday night and the place wan't very packed, I'd say at about 2/3 capacity when we walked in at about 9:30pm but became less and less packed at the night progressed. Â There was a great cumbia band there, but the music was definitely too loud, Â there was no chance at a conversation, and yet the dancefloor was virtually empty. Â
The atmoshere was very cozy and welcoming. Â The service was great, even though out server was taking care of 1/2 the people in the restaurant we never had to wait long for our drinks and he was very friendly. Â He even brought us chips, salsa and guacamole even though the kitchen was closed and he saw that we were disappointed.
The mojitos were pretty good and the beer was cheap (no beer was over $4.50, most were $3.50)
Cons: Â Music too loud, closes at 12am.
Pros: Great atmoshpere, great service
Good food and a great beer selection. They had New Belgium Fat Tire, a New Belgium Seasonal (which was Skinny Dip), and Stone IPA on tap (as well as others). All three great beers, and enough to make me quite content with the Beer selection. I had a "greek quesadilla" and it was really good. Though there were less simple things on the menu that I'm sure would've been good as well. I just wasn't that hungry. I had my fill of beer.
Review Source: