I'm new to the Tallahassee area (actually I live in GA, but visit my girlfriend here). Being from Kentucky, I've visited a significant amount of dive bars in and around both Louisville and Nashville. These kind of bars are around every corner. I have to admit that I've been spoiled by the places of my past and I've yet to experience anything in Tallahassee that comes close to them...until I went to the Leon Pub. The first night I went there it was around 830 on a Wednesday and the bar had a max of 12 people. Very laid back, Mike behind the bar was attentive and down to earth guy, and the people were a mix of hipster and working professionals. I spent most of my time marveling over the pages of beers to choose from. Luckily they had  Anchor Porter, which I have a hard time finding down here. The people seemed to be laid back and just enjoying a beer after work. I would almost categorize this as a neighborhood bar with frequent regulars, but definitely inviting to strangers as myself. In Nashville, people will often strike up conversations with you and offer to buy you a shot or something...I've never experienced that kind of hospitality in Tallahassee. I'm not complaining, but people definitely keep to themselves around here. I like it.
I ended up going back a few nights later and the service was awesome again. I waited about 5 seconds at the bar before our order was taken. Great (real) bar, mix of people, vintage decor, cool music, and an excellent selection of beer!