Dashboard

BIZ MENU
0% 0% 0% 0%

Leave a review or a tip...


Reviews & Tips

  • 0

    To be honest, there are not a whole lot of restaurants in the Anderson Valley. It is small and a very tight-knit community. But this does not mean you will be lacking in terms of wine, beer, food, and hospitality. Libby's is one of the few restaurants in the valley that serves dinner. The food is terrific! I am always amazed at how Mexican food in wine country (Napa, Sonoma, Anderson Valley, Paso Robles, etc.) on average is a lot better than the Mexican food you find around the bay area. Libby's is no exception. They open at around 5pm and if you have a large party or are in the valley during a weekend event you best make reservations. They have may A. Valley wines and a great beer selection. I really like their burritos, carnitas, and deserts. Usually the specials are terrific... but I can't seem to deviate from my go to dishes. You will not be dissapointed!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    We live in the PHX area and frequent New Mexico quite a bit.  So, we love our Mexican food and prepared in so many variations.  After wine tasting in the area, we were looking for a good restaurant.  We inquired at several wineries and a brewery and they all suggested Libby's.  When we found out it was a Mexican restaurant....so unexpected, we were all for it!

    It was a Tuesday night, so not very many patron's, the service was a little on the slow side as it was only what seemed as the family working that evening.  Once we got our drinks and ordered........man o man, it was absolutely delicious.  The flavors in each of our dishes, they know what they are doing.  Generous portions...nice surprise, we had left overs which we used for breakfast the next day.  

    This place is no frills, but great food.  We had friendly service and for a table of 5 with drinks only came out to 90.00 bucks w/o tip.  Not too shabby for the wine country.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Excellent mexican food that will have you wanting to come back for more!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I know, five stars.  But this place is well worth it.

    I was just trying to plan my honeymoon in Anderson Valley and remembered when I ate Libby's.  The al pastor was delicious.  I mean, I come from the town with the highest Mexican population outside of southern Cali -- and this al pastor was likely the best I've ever had.  

    All I know is that I'm excited to be going back in a couple months.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Not to be missed.  It gets all the stars because it's a good value, and we such a great lunch here. Retro decor--but very tidy.  The service was attentive, and the food is excellent. There was a mix of locals and out of towners--always a good sign.  I wish that we had a Mexican restaurant like this in our town. The flavors are super clean and fresh, not that yucky cheesy and goopy kind of Mexican food that seems to be endemic in California.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Best mexican food i have ever had.  we ordered camarones de diablo and carnitas, and some michaeladas.  camarones were fresh and super spicy.  carnitas were juicy and a bit crispy, in a good way.  i will definitely go back if i'm in the area again.  And service was fine.  They took my order and brought my order and said thanks when I left.  that's all i need.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Don't bother the service is terrible. I live down the road and I have been there three times, each time I was disappointed with the service. The hostess acted as if we were bothering her when we placed our order. There is better food in Boonville.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Wow! Who would've thought the best plate of Mexican food I've had in a long while would be in a tiny town in the countryside of Mendocino County! My food was absolutely excellent, as was reported by everyone else in my party. We all cleaned our plates to the last bite. They also carry local beer and wine from the Anderson Valley, so no let-downs on the beverages, either. The service provided by this little family outfit is great and laid-back. The interior decor is *restrained* (=very basic), but it doesn't matter since the food is so, so good. Go there! It's yummy!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    The food there is just amazing if your driving through Anderson valley town it's a Mexican food restaurant you don't want to miss.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Best carnitas ever. The only reason it's only 4 stars is because service is not the friendliest. But if you're ever in these parts do yourself a favor and order the carnitas.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Libby's lived up to the "Yelp Hype". Delicious food, prepared fresh, and served with a smile. If you're staying in the Anderson Valley or just passing through, this is must-stop. The carnitas will knock your sox off!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Before I start harpin', let me preface my review by mentioning that my opinion was based on at least 5 dining experiences over a 5 year period.

    While offering a wide array of "authentic" Mexican food and even some American favorites (WTF?), Libby's borders on inedible (harsh, I know) and what Libby's considers "service", is virtually non-existent.

    Anderson Valley sees a lot of brightlighters and I can understand how that might get you can-kicky. That being said, I surprised by the positive reviews because this is truly one of the rudest dining establishments in Poleeko.

    If you are a DIY'er with low expectations, you might "enjoy" dining at Libby's. If you consider yourself an average person, know what you're getting yourself into. If you're high-maintanence, stay away. If you're extremely patient and enjoy people watching (with a heat on), you might have fun.

    Familiarize your with this pre-Libby's-dining checklist:

    Libby's operates on their own terms and their hours of operation seem to vary. I would send a carrier pigeon or smoke signals since they don't answer their phone.

    Expect little to no hospitality, even if you're with a local. Grab a menu and seat yourself, even if it's at a dirty table. I've witnessed people standing, waiting to be acknowledged, even when things were slow.

    Think ahead, order additional drinks or plan ahead and bring your own.

    It's a shame that this is the only place to eat in Philo. If Lemon's (Philo Market) is open (and dependent on how hungry you are) find something to eat there, if not, (quickly) turn around and find something in Boonville.

    In short, don't gorm at Libby's, pike to (Boont or) the briny if you want something bahl.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    My friends highly recommend the food at Libby's, but sadly we never got to eat it due to bad attitude from the staff.  We arrived pretty close to closing time with a large group.  It's no problem at all that they couldn't accommodate us.  It is, however, a problem to be insanely rude about it to my very sweet and polite friend who inquired.  I don't come to Philo very often, but I certainly won't be coming back here when I do.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    We were honeymooning in the Anderson Valley and it seemed like all the locals kept telling us to try Libby's for the best eats around.... so we stopped in for lunch after doing some wine-tasting one day. I'm a huge carnitas fan, so I ordered carnitas -- which turned out to be absolutely the best I've ever had (and I honestly don't think that was just the wine talking, either!). Service was sweet and pretty prompt, even though they were packed that day (I guess they almost always are). The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is because the atmosphere could use a little improvement... but the carnitas alone definitely makes it worth the trip. Yum!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    This is a little gem, so hard to believe it's in a TINY town like Philo- it definitely rivals the best of SF, SJ, and OAK towns. Very fresh, VERY delicious- best carnitas I've had in ages! No fat, nice and crispy...authentic tacos with just the meat, tomatillo salsa, a little onion/cilantro- perfection :) Burritos are also amazing- large, flavorful and all around tasty.
    I wasn't the biggest fan of the pico de gallo, but that's not due to freshness, only lack of salt/spice which can be easily fixed. They also have Mexican coke on hand-mmmm!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Delicious, fresh, homestyle Mexican food just like (your) mom used to make.  We stop here nearly every time we pass through Philo, and I admit to a little sulking if we don't.
     First, the chips and salsa are fantastic.  I love the thick, rustic homemade chips, and the pico de gallo is always fresh and bright.  The guacamole is very good as well.  They also offer a salsa diabla (which is excellent) and a tomatillo salsa, which I've never tried.
     My fiancé has the carnitas here almost as a rule...they're just that good. They're like, Once Upon a Time in Mexico, shoot-the-chef-good.  The plate includes enough meat for about four huge tacos, so it's perfect for sharing.  It's always fresh, served hot, and crisped to perfection.  It's never greasy or leaden...a can't-miss.  
     The pollo asado is also wonderful.  It seems like they cook it really quickly over a very high heat, giving the outside a nicely browned crust while the inside stays juicy and tender.  The chicken soft tacos Or tostada are equally wonderful.  I love that the tostada stays crunchy, it's not overloaded with beans or sauce or lettuce, none of that bullshit.  Yet the toppings are plentiful and evenly dispersed so you get a little of everything with each bite...*drool*
     I always think that when a Mexican restaurant includes hamburgers on their menu, it's strictly for noobs or white people.  I've yet to order a burger in a Mexican restaurant anywhere.  However, today these two dudes having lunch a few tables over both ordered burgers and they looked Really good, and included a ~heap~ of beautiful, thick-cut homemade fries.  They were visibly Very happy with their Mexican burger decision.
     The downsides to this restaurant are few and not particularly grievous.  One, they get busy and Libby is frequently the only server.  We've always been seated and able to place our order promptly, but it's getting the check that seems to be delayed on occasion.  Another, and this is purely hearsay, but supposedly the service can be surly.  I've never experienced or witnessed it.  Lastly, they close for lunch at two o'clock and are not open Sundays.
     Altogether, this is a great little spot in the middle of nowhere.  I'd be way fatter from eating here as much as possible if it wasn't such a long drive haha...Don't miss it!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    So I am sometimes a hard judge when it comes to mexican places. I always compare the cooking to grandmas and thats only because its the best.

    The wife and I had just finished wine tasting at one of the local bars and we asked for a place to eat at and we were told Libby's, and that we just had to get there before 2 when they close. Well it was 1:19 and we figure that we should just go straight there.

    We arrive and the place is fully packed there was only one table open so we grab it like there is no tomorrow. Waitress comes over gives us the menu and first tells us that they are out of chicken. The wife orders the mole burrito special with al pastor and I get the Al pastor plate. When the food arrived I took the first bite of my Al pastor and hands down this is some of the best I have ever had, because of this awesome dish I will be back. The wife's mole burrito had a great kick to it, I had to sneak more then one bite.

    At around 1:50 we saw the staff running to close the blinds and turn the signs around. They don't joke about closing at 2. So glad we made it. Next time we will have to try the carnitas, the table next to us would not stop talking about them and said that they can't find anything that good down south.

    So if your passing through Philo and you want to a bite to eat stop here, plus its the only place in town to eat.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I just can't understand all the stars from other Yelpers, as Libby's is truly atrocious. The meat in my chicken super burrito had such a foul taste and smell that  I couldn't eat it. Seriously disgusting. The only part of it that was edible were the beans...all 10 of them. My partner had a Caesar salad...the dressing was just oil and vinegar. His chicken was bad too.

    The food arrived within 3 minutes of ordering it. That's too fast! It was clearly microwaved.  Waitress was clueless about the decent but small wine selection. Lackluster service, no offer to remove dirty plates or refill water glasses. No questions asked about why our meals were virtually untouched either!

    Libby's is the only restaurant in Philo so my recommendation is to eat in Boonville!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I cannot come up with a reason to dock Libby's a star. Sure, it's a Mexican diner in Philo, CA, but I would go out of my way to return. I ate at some of the Mendocino area's finest restaurants, and none of them warrants the highest Yelp praise. Libby's does.
    It's hours can be tricky, so pay attention; showing up for lunch at 2:15 will get you nada. In this case, that means you'd miss out on really excellent, saucy al pastor tacos and flat-freaking-awesome carnitas.
    No matter what form you choose (burrito, taco, smoothie...) make certain you order carnitas. They are a triumph of tender, flavorful meat shot through with gloriously chewy, caramelized bits.
    Service is lovely, and you can get a wide range of beers and some of the valley's best wines.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    All I really have to say about this place is.... carnitas. It is amazing. Order it and devour it.

    My BF and I visited Anderson Valley for a night and stayed at the Anderson Valley Inn right across 128 from Libby's, so after a full day of wine tasting we walked over for an early dinner. It may have had something to do with the fact I was a little buzzed from the excessive amount of wine I had tasted earlier that day, but this was honestly the BEST carnitas I have ever had. It was textbook - nice and crispy on parts of the outside but still really juicy. The BF got a chicken burrito which looked great and he said he liked. We also got some guac and chips, the guac had a good kick to it and was great with the carnitas. I had a glass of wine from a local winery (hey, when in Rome, right?) and I don't think I've ever seen such a generous pour. They pour wine the way I pour for myself at home.

    If I'm back out in Anderson Valley anytime soon, which I hope I am, I absolutely know where I'm going for dinner.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    They close at 8pm, which we did not know ahead of time.  We had made reservations for 7:30 and arrived 10 minutes late.  I think the waitress might have been miffed but she didn't show it.  And anyway, by the time we were done, there were still 2 other tables eating.  

    The waitress listed 3 dishes they were out of, which I think is a good sign about a restaurant, right?  That they're so popular, they actually sell out.

    I had the carnitas burrito, which I enjoyed.  Except I asked for no beans and was given beans.

    Boyfriend had the pastor (?) entree, which I think is pork marinated in some relatively exotic juices like pineapple and orange.  I could be confusing it with something else on the menu.  We both thought it was very tasty.

    My sister had their enchilada, which she actually did not like very much.  

    I really liked their salsa dip.  The tomatoes just burst in my mouth.

    None of us are experts when it comes to Mexican food.  I wouldn't say it was the best Mexican I've ever had, and I'm not actually sure I have a "best".  But what I ordered, I liked (except the beans).

    Service was no-nonsense.  If we're back in the area and in the mood for Mexican, we'll definitely stop by again.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    There is no better Mexican food. At least not on this planet. If you don't dig the food here, then frankly I pity you.

    As I said before: the al pastor and carnitas are divine. The two shrimp entrees should be on the divine list as well.

    Yeah, the service can be slow, but hey, you're in Philo, what else are you going to do in the evening?? Just enjoy the food and relax.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Ms. Libby?  Please send some family over here to Fort Bragg and open another Libby's Restaurant please!??!!

    First timer at Libbys after a trip inland From the coast (coincidentally there was a tsunami surge on the coast today too) and friends telling us it was a MUST stop here in the beautiful Anderson Valley.  OMG!  The meat, the food, everything here is to die for!!  I especially loved the chicken and now can't get it out of my mind.  My friend had the Super Nachos and they not only were beautiful to look at but the most delicious nachos ever!  We traditionally have Mexican food for dinner here in Fort Bragg on Friday night but nothing here even remotely can hold a candle to Libby so can't do it.  I may never be able to eat Mexican food in Fort Bragg ever again.

    I see a drive to Philo next Friday in our future!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    No trip to Anderson Valley is complete without lunch or dinner at Libby's.

    The menu is packed with flavor - some fairly authentic, like the unbelievably simple, yet amazing carnitas and some items are a nod to American classics, like the 'latin-lover' hamburger with maybe the best kettle fries you've ever had.  

    Libby's doesn't claim to be "Authentic" as some people seem to bitch about on Yelp. Her local customers are a mix of sophisticated diners and crusty old FOX News viewers, and her menu needs to reflect the needs of a diverse demographic. (Like the fact she makes insane Rajas Tacos but has to call them 'Roasted Veggie Tacos' so Fox News viewers will order them too.

    Libby's secret to producing great food is that she sources top quality produce and meat, cooks with a minimalist style and to order. The salad greens alone are amazing. And after a day of boozing at the wineries a big old salad in lieu of rice and beans can do wonders for mind and bowels.

    Regarding some of the low scores for service. Some of it is valid. There is one waitress (who mostly works nights) who is sassy and fun with most locals but can be short and rude at times with weekenders and tourists. Everyone else is wonderful, but they don't and shouldn't put up with guff from pissy tourists. I've heard some pretty unreasonable requests out of ignorance and a sense of  wine-country entitlement. It gets busy. Be patient! You are in a sparsely populated area - things work differently, and despite what your mommy told you, you are NOT a princess and the sun does not rise from and set upon your ass crack!!!

    AND SPECIFICALLY to the sniveling little city douche in the Petty Coat at lunch the other day. To you I say...

    'taking 3 minutes to order a super-burrito with salsa-on-the-side to accompany your $80 bottle of Goldeneye Pinot, is retarded on so, so many levels I'm not sure where to begin. Your girlfriend deserves better, she just doesn't know it yet.'

    TO THOSE SAVVY TRAVELERS, I say...

    'Buuuurppp!!! I can still taste my perfectly cooked chili relleno from lunch'.

    Don't miss Libbys!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Good eats.
    We had carnitas and they were spot on.
    You have to be going there to get there; but it's worth it.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I lived in San Francisco's Mission District for many years, and was surrounded by the best Mexican food that food-crazed city had to offer, but Libby's tops them all.  All of their food is wonderful but I especially like the carnitas.  They're probably as close to perfection as you can get in this world.  This is real, authentic gourmet Mexican food.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Libby's doesn't look like much from the outside - or the inside either for that matter.  But the food is awesome and that's what really matters.  I had the super burrito with chicken - it was  huge, packed with chicken, and served with delicious beans and spicy guacamole.  My husband had the carnitas and loved every bite.  The service is lukewarm but quick.  The bottom line is that this is a basic, neighborhood place with authentic, delicious eats.  Next time we're in the area, we will be back.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    It has been a lifetime journey to find the best Al Pastor tacos...and I am glad to say I've stumbled into them in Philo CA!  Very authentic tacos, with homemade corn tortillas, meat onions cilantro.  Simple and just perfect tangy, spicy flavor.

    Carnitas also amazing  We made a special stop at the end of our trip to go back for more!  Just as good the second time.

    Service was friendly and very attentive.  Worth going out of your way to try these if you are a true Pastor afficianado.

    Be sure to wash the tacos down with homemade Michelada.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I can't imagine driving here for the food from the Bay Area but based on location, price and quality, libbys is solid.  If it was located in the Mission district in SF, it would only be average fare.  We stopped to eat en route to Fort Bragg and it was good!  Nice local feel to the place.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Best food in the Anderson Valley if you can get there when they're open. They're closed on Sundays and Mondays and then, like many other businesses in the Valley, take off for a good part of the winter in January and February.

    Bests: Carnitas, carnitas, carnitas. Al pastore is a close second. Caesar salad is delicious. And I have grown addicted to her Michiladas. Perhaps the best selection of wines in any Mexican restaurant in California. When I receive my meal I email photos of her carnitas to friends to taunt then. I usually receive a distressed response within a minute. Generous portions. She makes her own chips. And she doesn't advertise it, but she cans and sells some of her sauces. ALL her sauces and salsas are divine. If you want to eat lower on the food-chain, you can order the tostada or soft tacos with carnitas versus going straight to the carnitas dinner. The last time I was there she offered a wet burrito special. Don't ask me why, but I selected carnitas for the meat.

    Worst: I can't seem to order anything but her carnitas. These are slow, cooked chunks of pork that she finished on a grill to caramelize it to perfection. They are NOT deep-fried so you can rationalize that they're health food. Or, at least I do. And when she has specials -- generally seafood -- I freak out at deciding whether or not to get a bowl of seafood stew, a whole fried fish, or carnitas. As you may know, anxiety is not good for digestion. Thus I suffer. Regardless of what I order, I wish I were a cow with an additional stomach or two for room for another dinner.

    It's a family-run business, so if there's a crowd it can get slow. Please be patient. I'm not certain if they understand what Yelp is. i told one of the daughters that they've been getting good reviews online and she looked slightly concerned if not suspicious. They're not web-savvy, so there's no website or online menu to review in advance. Regardless of what I've written, she has quite a few options other than carnitas (chicken, shrimp, carne asada, sopes, burgers, salads, veg, cheese) in various forms (quesadillas, dinners, tacos, enchiladas, tostadas, burritos) and a large wine and beer list and something called Ku margarita, which I think is a wine margarita. They don't have a liquor license so there's no tequila. So, yes, it's roughing it out there.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Great salsa here, fresh & spicy.   I'd agree on skipping the rellenos, but everything else is so good.  I imagine this is what home-made mexican food tastes like.  

    This is a must-stop on the way to Mendo from the ba.  They seem to have pretty limited hours though.  For 10 years we drove by and they were closed either due to season or day of week.   Finally, we saw them open on a fri night.  The place was packed and plenty of to-go orders were being filled.  There were only 2 people working there, so you have to patient., but it's worth the wait.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    On our way home from a wedding in Albion we had attended the day before, my boyfriend and I were starving for some breakfast.  We saw that Libby's was open and decided to give it a try.  What a great idea!!  

    I had the Huevos con Chorizo.  I had no idea I would be able to get such awesome chorizo in the middle of HWY 128, but it was delicious!  My boyfriend had pancakes and bacon and there was nothing left on the plate when he was done.  

    The service was good, a little slow for only 4 tables occupied, but totally worth the wait.  If you're on HWY 128 and hungry, I recommend you try this place out.  Can't wait till we're near there again!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    5/29 - Had a business meeting in the area today, so I went to Yelp for suggestions - and Libby's came up with positive reviews - so here I am.  Most of the postings are right on target - small town Mexican restaurant.  It is ran by I believe just 2 people.  Very friendly and welcoming, the place was very clean and plenty of tables/counter space.  Service was not to bad - but there were only about 12 of us in the place.

    Most recommended the Carnitas, so that is what I had - generous portion of meat - yes I took some home.  There was no way I could eat the entire plate.

    My guests had tacos and a burrito - they were happy with their selection.  The burrito was big, and was without the rice in it too (guest did not want the rice included).  Tacos were simple, Mexican style.

    So, if you are in the area - doing a little wine tasting and need to have a bite to eat - stop by Libby's.  You will get a good meal at a good price.

    They are open for lunch 11:30 - 2 pm and for dinner.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Yum!! I'm a huge fan of Mexican food, and usually stick withy my normal fare of burritos or something simple, but after reading the reviews on here I had to try the carnitas! Once again Yelpers didn't let me down, AMAZING!! The portions were super big, and I had plenty left over. I'm a big fan of chips and will say theirs were also fantastic, house made if I'm not mistaken. Contrary to what others experienced  our service was super fast! Loved it, glad we stopped in!

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Some of the best Mexican food I've ever had - I echo the other reviewers that the carnitas and al pastor are fantastic. They're also doing some interesting specials now - fish in a black bean sauce, steak sandwich with arugala. Amazingly good, actually, even though they weren't Mexican cuisine. Try a Michelada beer - with ice, lime, Maggie juice, spicy salt around the rim. DELICIOUS. Skip Alicia's in Boonville and head to Libby's always.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Pretty much the only place worth eating in Philo - the carnitas and al pastor are fantastic!  Skip the chili relleno, however.  Good beer and wine list, and great chips and salsa.

    The service here SUCKS.  I mean, rivals some of the worst I've had.  This past weekend when we were here, we were treated to an older, surly waitress who clearly hated being there.  She told us that she "couldn't make" the michelada on the drink menu because she was just too busy (there were about 15 people in the restaurant).  The food takes a long time to come out.

    If you're staying in Philo, chances are, you'll have to eat here at least once because you won't want to drive all the way into Boonville.  The food is good, but you've been warned.

    You might want to call in your order and just get it to go.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Even from Oakland where I live, this is a destination place - for the carnitas and other wonderful dishes. (My wife had multiple food orgasim from the carnitas.)  I've been traveling this road for years to visit my dad and lives on the coast.

    Check the hours, as they are short, and call ahead to make sure they are open.  You can make a day of it.  Visit the wonderful Hendy Woods just a hop away.  (Or if like me, nuts over old growth, try the Montgomery Woods - a 'little' drive from here.)  You'll see the old growth trees from the highway near the fruit/juice stand...sorry got distracted.

    The food is great! Great food up there to eat and eat, then camp in the redwood forest, then to eat the next day there. Watch out for mountain lions...kidding.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    Delicious.  Try the guacamole - spicy and super fresh.  Their carne asada burrito was awesome, and there were some ravings from my friends about the carnitas.  Service was pretty quick, actually, but the place wasn't packed.  Friendly staff, great food.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I've eaten here a few times. The first encounter was pleasant, the food good - slightly above-average diner fare.

    The second and third times - let's say that it was a fabulous exercise in patience.

    The second and third visits - my traveling companion and I placed orders for SANDWICHES and waited 45 minutes and an hour respectively - long enough for me to have to send my friend out to the truck to retrieve my glucose tablets - I'm a diabetic, and while I rarely make that a fact relating to anyone other than myself, I was beyond annoyed that it took so long when we were either the ONLY couple in the restaurant, or one of two couples in the joint.

    Lousy, lousy service.

    Give this place a pass.

    Review Source:
  • 0

    I hesitate to write this review. Libby's is a treasure of Mendocino county. And on weekends it's not easy to get a seat in the place. And there are days when I've gone in and discovered that my all-time favorite dish -- carnitas -- has run out. So why tell the tourists about it and overrun the place?

    But loyalty to the Artiste known as Libby forces my hand. Libby is an artiste and chef extraordinaire. We have discussed her quests throughout Michoacan, Mexico to sample and compare cuisine. And because I desire to bring goodness and light to all and because you twist my arm I'll spill the beans.

    Libby serves the best carnitas that I've ever had. I may venture to say that her carnitas are the best pork dish I've ever had -- and I love my pork in all forms from all lands. The carnitas are seasoned and slow cooked in a little water on the stove top and then finished on the grill. They are served as large, caramelized chunks of tender pork. Her caesar salad (another barometer I use to evaluate a restaurant) is unique and deeply satisfying: more tangy and spicy than fishy served with deep fried twists of tortilla in lieu of croutons and a healthy sprinkling of cilantro. Her salsas, dressings, moles, and sauces are all made in-house and have been known to make me weep with pleasure. Her weekend seafood specials are not to be missed (unless, of course, it means eschewing the carnitas). Her carne asada is a well-seasoned and perfectly grilled t-bone steak. Her al pastore is a spicy, orangy stew of pork. Moan....

    Or if you want something more "American", then have her burger. She also serves one of the best burgers I've ever had. They're served on Bruce Bread buns (baked in the Valley) with the perfect toppings.

    But why go to Libby's just for a burger?

    She probably has one of the top 10 wine lists of any Mexican restaurant in California, boasting the finest of the Anderson Valley, not to mention an excellent selection of Mexican and Anderson Valley beers. But my favorite drink is her Michilada: beer (Corona, of course), lime, maggi juice in a frozen glass over ice with a rim dipped in lime, salt, and chili. Perfect on a hot, summer day.

    Okay, service is slow. But it's a small operation and it's the Valley. And if you think her service is bad, you obviously haven't been eating at many places in the Valley. So kick back and relax. Have a glass or two or something. And to end it all have a blackberry ice cream sundae or her home made flan for dessert.

    But don't take my table or my carnitas from me.

    Review Source:
Nearby Suggested Listings Close

Warning: include(/home/indulgery.com/htdocs/db_down.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/indulgery.com/htdocs/classes/database.class.php on line 157

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/home/indulgery.com/htdocs/db_down.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/local/lib/php:/usr/share/pear:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/indulgery.com/htdocs/classes/database.class.php on line 157