Not very Irish other than some Guinness mirrors and such on the wall but, the food we had on this visit was really good. Â I got a cheeseburger with bacon and grilled onions and my buddy got an order of wings. Â We were both happy and frankly, somewhat surprised. Â Dining options in Keystone are rather limited and I would list McHenry's as a solid choice.
Service was friendly though a bit slow and it's a little scary for the future when the manager comes around saying you will get a 10% discount on your bill if you pay with cash. Â The biggest negative was all the Orange and Blue clad Gator fans there watching football but, I don't hold that against McHenry's as that money spends too. Â Go Noles! :)
Plenty of Irish whiskey available but not much Irish beer other than Guinness (draft). Â Large selection otherwise. Â Very pleasant, airy interior. Â Very pleasant airy waitress. Â Great menu for a sports bar, especially for this little town. Â Hope it makes it because the Philly Cheese steak sandwich was the best I've ever had (including some in Philly). Â Prices reasonable. Wings were pretty good too. Â We sat in the bar but I think it had a section that was restaurant only sort of thing that might be quieter.
Review Source: