McNally Grill & Pub

I've had terrible food experience here again and again.  Most recently, my caesar salad that I ordered was made with MAYONNAISE.  The waitress made my salad with mayo, and brought me a side of mayo.  After I tried the salad, and the side of "dressing" (and everyone else at the table tried as well) I brought it to the attention of the waitress who said that was "their version" of caesar and it "always looks like that"...never once did she double check to make sure she/the kitchen wasn't using the wrong thing.  Guess what, I know mayo when I see, taste, and smell it.  It was disgusting.  I sent it back and didn't get another meal.  Not impressed with the carelessness of food or the waitstaff's attitude.  Needless to say, I will NEVER eat here again and I will never recommend this restaurant to anyone I know.

In a party of 9 people, 6 of us were truly appalled by the food. Gigantic, sloppy portions that tasted straight out of the freezer.

Secondly, for a place that was practically dead, they were out of half of the items we ordered. Coleslaw? No. Tortellini? No. Apple crisp? Nope!

They also think that grilled vegetables = boiled/steamed soggy vegetables and that a fresh salad = brown wilted lettuce.

Let's get into what was the worst:

- Chicken Carbonara (out of tortellinis and looked like a pile of white cheesy vomit).

- Fettucini Alfredo must have been sitting out too long because the butter and cheese was completely separated and was reminiscent of leftover Fettucini Alfredo that you microwave the next day

- Chicken Parm was burned and the sauce was crusty.

The good?

- Buffalo wings (mild) and garlic chili wings were not half bad and they didn't skimp on the celery.

- While portions were grossly gigantic, at least they don't skimp on the food.

- while none of us loved our desserts, we didn't hate them either. Again, good portions. The lava cake was a little too "chocolate flan" texture for my taste.

One person at our table said, "it's a good thing we're not here to review this place". Little did they know.

This is $10 a plate fare, not $16-$20 a plate fare and you could get better food at your local Applebees.