The pizza is very good. During peak hours you can sometimes see dough thrown by their 3-time world-champion thrower, Michael Shepherd. There is also a Kenton, OH store, but I have not been to that one.
If you travel past Bellefontaine or are in the Indian Lake area, it is worth the 8-10 mile detour to visit Michael Angelo's. Rushsylvania does not have many attractions beyond being a great mid-western small town, so Michael Angelo's can be your excuse.
I like their subs best. Just a great balance of good bread, plenty of meat and veggies, and packed around a nice blend of spices.
You never need to consider traffic or parking - there is no rush hour in Rushsylvania.