Old Erie

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  This used to be one of our favorite restaurants, but we are unlikely to return. We have not been there about 3 years, and we were completely disappointed tonight!! First, we noticed the paper menu with water stains, rather than the professionally done menu of the past that highlighted the history of the building, and the culinary background and experience of the owner. That alone was kind of a clue that things would be different. We wondered if there was change in management. I think the quality of the rest of the meal answered that question for us.. After we ordered, the bread and butter with the traditional lentils were brought. The bread was unheated. Simply put, the lack of the special touch of warm bread was another
  clue that the quality was down a notch. We missed the traditional garlic and oil with spices that formerly we could drizzle on the bread to start things off. According to the waitress,that was discontinued about two years ago. My wife ordered Tuscan vegetable soup which had a very good
  flavor. However, while taking a spoonful, in her mouth she found a small piece of "rubbery plastic" material that was in the soup. She took it out and we immediately showed the waitress. She apologized politely, and took it into the kitchen. We honestly thought the cook or a manager would come to our table to apologize/ explain, or to make even a modest adjustment to our bill, but no further mention whatsoever would come about. The crusted white fish was OK, but had soggy crumbs and an overwhelming taste of butter. The Julienned squash has little flavor,and excess butter.
  My salmon with crusted potato was also acceptable, but the "crusted potato" seemed to be frozen hash browns. To top it all off, I ordered a low fat white milk with my meal. I drank about one third and realized that there was black specks floating on top. Looking further, I realized that there was
  dirt or left over food stuck on the INSIDE of the glass. I brought this up to the waitress, and she said something like "I'll have to speak to those boys." (Meaning, the dishwasher boys, I guess.)
  I was kind of hoping she would bring me a new clean glass of milk, but, again, no further mention of this was made. All in all, this was a disappointment from the memorable and quality dining experience we always had in the past here. We live 50 miles away and occasionally stopped when passing by on the Thruway. We do not plan to return again!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 07.14.13 Sue R.

  • Report
• 0

  We stop by whenever we pass thorough town. Easy to get to from highway and the food is always great! Love the daily pizza and the homemade spaetzle.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 02.13.12 Jo Anna G.

  • Report
• 0

  Really really good food never had a bad plate not just down home food they trained chefs that know what they are doing a special place to eat you can dress up or down most times do not need a reservation now the waiters and waiter-assess  most time we try to go when Derek is on he is the best treats everyone awesome no matter if your there to spend a little or a lot but there r a few that are well not so good we once order something requesting cheese only it came with tomatoes when we mention the fact she really wanted us to just remove the tomatoes ,, now we all know it's not good if you have a allege to them or even just being able to still taste them ,,, you pay enough for this great food it should come the way u asked for this however this is no a reflection on the restaurant what so ever ya know bad apple in every bunch.  EVERYONE SHOULD TRY THIS PLACE AT LEAST ONCE!
  
  T.V at the bar area

  Review Source:

  Posted on 07.02.11 Erica H.

  • Report