Old Mill Tavern Reviews | Chester Restaurants & Bars

0

1 dollar domestic "mugs" are 10 oz plastic cups. The chick bartender had no idea what she was doing and was blatantly wiping sweat off herself with a napkin while still behind the bar. You get what you pay for here, and that ain't much!

Review Source:

Posted on 07.18.13 Henry K.

Report

0

Went back last night...not nearly as good, service was HORRIBLE. I MEAN HORRIBLE. Â Tall red headed waitress had a horrible personality, didn't ask us how our food was, didn't want to refill our water glasses, frankly, she was lazy...left a horrible taste in my mouth. Â Also, the Nachos Grande are not nearly as good as they used to be, the cole slaw was HORRIBLE and I mean HORRIBLE, I had to send it back and the buffalo chicken tenders were mehhhhhh...

Not happy with this second experience.

Review Source:

Posted on 06.03.13 J W.

Report

0

I went here as part of a group on Saturday for lunch. Â This restaurant is wood paneled, with a bar (tvs are here at the bar). Â Our group sat in the back at tables which were pushed together. Â

I was told that this place is known for it's selection of 26? beers and for its burgers (the meat is from the local butcher). Â Well....this made me want to try at least the burger and I DO NOT order burgers regularly since I am very fussy and usually end up either sending them back to the kitchen or taking them home to cook myself. Â So I held my breath and tried a burger. Â Well, I was NOT disappointed. Â Very very tasty, large and cooked to perfection. Â I also had the fresh cut fries (a tad limp) and pickles, onion, lettuce and tomato on my buger.....very very happy with the burger!

Our waitress was young, very friendly, very competent and put up with our large, sometimes indecisive group. Â All in all, I would recommend this restaurant. Â The food was good, the service was excellent and I loved the burger!

Review Source:

Posted on 04.08.13 Kat B.

Report

0

It doesn't look like much from outside - we were very pleasantly surprised! Â It is quite charming inside. The menu is great as is the beer. Â We'll be back very soon!

Review Source:

Posted on 02.10.12 Janet G.

Report

0

Good beer selection, fantastic clams and the teriyaki skirt steak salad was amazing! Â The wings were good too. Â This will be a local favorite of mine for a while. Â The service was good, although it took us a while to get a beer at the bar - Â I think that was due to it being a Wednesday/$1 pint night. Â good crowd and and overall ambiance of the bar.

Review Source:

Posted on 02.02.12 Danielle L.

Report

0

Standard town bar with a few TV's and the beer selection is standard. However, the burgers are the best you'll find in the area.

Review Source:

Posted on 02.02.12 Nicholas D.

Report

0

Nice place to hit after a hike in Black River Park and pass the Nature Conservancy office.

Good wings; the Atomic Habanero was at very, very spicy. Â Also had deserts for Mara's bakery. Â Had a few interesting beer selections on tap.

Review Source:

Posted on 05.03.11 Larry Y.

Report

0

I've been back twice in the last week and the burgers are the best in the area and I swear the draft beer is the coldest

Review Source:

Posted on 07.16.10 Eric F.

Report

0

Small, homey type of place - this is Chester we're talking about, a nice corner of Morris County - and eating here is almost like being in someone's house, cozy and intimate. The fish and chips slopped with malt vinager is delicious. Â It's not fancy, but I don't think they are aiming for that. Â The salads looked great, as did the philly cheesesteak lunch special. Â The lunch crowd is typically blue-blooded, blue hairs - again, this is a quiet part of the world, not meant to be the Port Authority at 42nd St. Â Definitely a great lunch spot.

Review Source:

Posted on 06.28.10 Marcus D.