Papa John's Pizza

Love PJ over any other pizza place. Between the pepperoncinis and garlic butter sauce, I'm in heaven! I live in a confusing intersection of alleys in Winona Lake and they never have a problem delivering in time. Also, they usually have the best deals on pizzas!

Agree that thin crust is nasty. It tastes like insecticide.  Hand tossed is great. It's a little pricier than the other big chains and delivery is slow. The staff is a bit snotty, rude, and immature.

Their thin crust is lousy. Their hand-tossed is OK. They can never find my house and it always adds on 10 or 15 minutes to the delivery time, even though I'm less than 1/2 mile away from their store and live on one of the major streets in town (that is relatively well-lit with streetlights). Their pizza isn't really that bad, but their service is. Dominos delivers consistently in less than half the time it takes PJ's to deliver.