The Prime Rib Restaurant & Wine Cellar

What a huge disappointment this restaurant was.  I ordered prime rib because after all, it is a prime rib restaurant.  The meat was not served medium rare as I asked, it was cold and it was dry.  I asked if it was cut off the roast fresh, the waitress said yes, but there is no way that could be true unless the beef was from the day before.  Awful.

The soup was excellent and this is why I gave the place 3 stars.  There was so much chicken in the chicken noodle soup that I almost wished there wasn't because I thought I would fill up eating it long before the main course.  It was clearly homemade, the bread that came with it was quite good as well.

I liked the cloth napkins and I especially liked that our table was set when we arrived (we made reservations), they scored bonus points for that.  It is true what someone said about the utensils, a really good upgrade for this restaurant would be to have matching, upgraded, high-quality flatware and steak knives.  Some things really stand out when they are not right.

Overall I would say this is a decent place to eat, just don't order the prime rib.

We were visiting the area and were told this restaurant was good by a merchant in town. Given that Gillette doesn't have much to offer except fast food and Applebees, this was an extremely pleasant surprise. It's not inexpensive but the quality and ambiance were wonderful. We had a delicious prime rib and friends had trout. We all raved about our meals. The vegetables were prepared very well too and the salad was fresh. We were visiting with friends who we hadn't seen in a while & the waitress was attentive but not intrusive. We were not rushed at all. We also asked for a different table than the one offered and they were pleasant about our request. I wouldn't hesitate to come back here if we want this type of meal. A nice surprise in Gillette.

fish n chips are excellent however you only get two pieces for $28. Prime rib is not seasoned it was tender however