Put In Bay Brewing Co

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  Our favorite place on the Island, bar none.  We spend a lot of weekends (and weekdays for that matter) at Put in Bay, and we love the PIB Brewery.  Love the staff, good food, and good beers.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 02.11.13 Cindy G.

  • Report
• 0

  Brew Co is my favorite bar on Put--in-Bay.  It tends to be a little less crowded, I think since its a bit on the end of all of the other major bars.  Their beer is great; I highly recommend the Summer Brew.  If it is Christmas in July, they make an awesome Christmas Ale (I say this hesitantly bc I know it is a very strong statement, but I think I like it even better than Great Lakes).  Food is good, they have the typical bar food and usually branch out with some creative cuisine as well.  I've never been served anything here that I didn't enjoy.  The Bartenders are very friendly, too.  There are only 3 restaurants I would ever recommend on PIB and this is one of them (side note: why do most PIB restaurants suck? lol).
  
  Only (potential) complaint is that I heard they no longer clear out the tables for dancing at night.. which is a major bummer because I have a lot of awesome memories at this bar!!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 11.25.12 Laura Y.

  • Report
• 0

  Very tasty food but service was lacking. Also bar very loud. Pizza was very good.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 10.07.12 Josh W.

  • Report
• 0

  Best pizza on the island by far. They do not deliver, but the island is small, so who cares. Avoid the beer that they make, but the food is fine, the staff is friendly, and they have plenty of beers that they don't make.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 08.08.12 Joe B.

  • Report
• 0

  Really liked this place.  The food was good (best burgers we had on the island).  Independent beer options are always a plus.  Went back another evening for the late night pizza and really liked that as well.  The service both times was good, attentive and talkative, just how a touristy place should be.  We would make this our favorite eatery for our trip to the island.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 07.24.12 Joe S.

  • Report
• 0

  I make it a point to stop here each time I visit the island. Full bar, seven original beers such as the watermelon wheat and the summer brew. You can purchase their authentic beer glasses and take home a growler of your favorite beer.
  
  Full menu! I love the sweet mango salsa and guacamole with the plantain chips. Try the walleye bites!
  
  Service is excellent, they are never too busy to serve you. Inside bar class plenty of seating and connects to the outside patio where there is another bar and seating for the smokers.
  
  Huge plasma TV inside.
  
  There is usually not a hostess on duty, so seat yourself!
  
  The watermelon wheat is my favorite; it is the most delicious, handcrafted beer I have ever tasted. Perfect for your summer island hopping trip.
  
  Be sure to tip your servers and your bartenders!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 05.30.12 Meghann T.

  • Report