Ye Olde Shack Restaurant & Lounge

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  I travel a LOT.  When I'm in a strange town, my mission is often to find a dive bar where I feel at home.  That's not always easy.  I often walk into a local dive bar and the locals look at me like I'm an alien from another world, or, worse yet, a banjo player.
  
  I entered the shack and was greeted warmly by the owner herself, who seemed pleased that I and my party were there, and, indeed, she was.  This is a restaurant/pub owner who truly enjoys meeting new people, and it shows
  
  The food....was well above average.  I had the "Shack Burger" and, let me tell you, it was outstanding!  The beef was fresh and tasty, the toppings were plentiful, and everything was prepared just like I requested.  I home run on this one.
  
  One of my dining companions had the Cuban sandwich  (Seriously???  A Cuban sandwich in Brookville??  How does that even happen??) and loved every bite of it.  Holly chose a fried fish sandwich and pronounced it very good indeed.
  
  I'd give this place a 5 if I could...yes, I liked it that much!  But it's smoking.  We were fortunate to be able to set on the patio and not have our food laced with smoke, but I CAN see where in the winter, when the patio isn't open, this could be an issue.
  
  Overall, a VERY positive experience.  We'll certainly be back!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 05.13.13 Rick G.

  • Report
• 0

  The food wasn't very good.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 02.21.09 F. B.

  • Report