Big Tony's Pizza

Upon a trip to Florida with friends, we wanted to venture into the 'towns' and not just stay in the touristy, Orlando area.  We set out to find a pizza shop and see how Florida pizza tasted compared to pizza back home... NY.  

We saw this place and how they claim to have 'NY style' so we said why not.  Its narrow when first entering here, but they have a larger dining room towards the back.  We ordered 3 waters, and a large cheese pizza w ricotta cheese on the side.

We went to gulp down the waters and about half way down the glass, we all stopped and stared at one another....Something was SO WRONG.  The water tasted like sulfur.  In NY we are lucky to have excellent water, especially in Westchester County so this was a huge and disgusting surprise.  To replace the water we asked for 3 Diet Cokes instead.

um.....SAME gross issue.  They must use the fake soda w the flavoring attached to the water line.  I'm sorry but Florida locals or not, no one wants to taste sulfur in anything.  I don't why they haven't shelled out the cash to install a water softener which will take away the taste and clean the water up.  If you have an establishment; this should be required. No excuses.

We managed to wolf down the pizza b/c we were legit starving but it was not exactly satisfying.  I wish we picked another place or perhaps some other food on the menu would have been more appetizing.

Sorry Big Tony, but New York, you are NOT.

Hey big tony please close this place you are misleading the public with this horrible "pizza" you are serving the public. It pisses me off to even call this stuff pizza.  One bad thing is ok but 93.00 worth of pizza with different toppings that all sucked is not acceptable.  The wings sucked the toppings sucked the fries sucked. All in all I truly don't know why this place is open there's no way the people can think anything about this is good. No sir not me. It won't let me leave no stars so I'll leave you one and that one star you should cut your wrists

This pizza place is awesome. Huge dining room and friendly staff. Here's what we tried:

Grandma's Pizza - Holy garlic, batman... this one had a great kick and is awesome as long as you don't have to talk to anybody for a few hours! Mozzarella, ricotta, romano, garlic, olive oil and red or white sauce. This one kicked butt.

Veggie Pizza - tons o' veggies. This one was also a winner. Their dough and sauce rock.

Pepperoni Pizza - lots of pepperonis... Excellent.

Breadsticks - a huge order of breadsticks. Almost like another whole pizza! Came with a huge order of marinara dipping sauce and garlic butter.