Like Pepe's, Bison Witches is one of my old school, go-to Norman eateries.  I've been eating here since before I could legally drink (let's just say that's a long while) and the food still satisfies.  Let me say that for me, Bison Witches is a deli, not a bar - so my review is from that point of view.  They have an incredibly-reasonably priced special that includes 1/2 a sandwich, a bread-bowl soup and a bag of chips.  I always get the Veggie sandwich on wheat, with the Portobello harvest grain soup and spicy (which equates to Ms. Vickey's jalapeño) chips.  DELICIOUS!!  While the inside could definitely use some "sprucing up", the food is still spot-on - If you're looking for convenient eats before a show at Opolis, Bison Witches is the place to hit up.
Review Source:I love Bison Witches for trivia night on Tuesdays! The crowd is pretty chill, the grilled cheese is a staple, and they are known for their Irish Trashcans - and I highly recommend the IT! We usually have really good service there, but that is partially because we have been going there every Tuesday for a couple of years now.
Friends also have the tortilla chicken salad every Tuesday - so it must be good!
bisonwitches= buy some sandwiches... get it?
that is what we used to say when we were in college...lol
a good variety of sandwiches to choose  from...
try the combo deal: 1/2 sandwich, bread bowl soups, and chips..
moved back to oklahoma so went back here...it has been years since my last visit and i have been craving their bread bowl soups and sandwiches...tasted the same....noticed you have a choice now in  bread (even wraps) for your sandwich and more variety of chips.
gets very crowded and loud...more of a college scene
avoid the evenings unless you want to drink...but for food..come during lunch time... earlier to avoid the crowd..
wish they had a second location ..that is bigger and more kid friendly because i love their sandwich & bread bowl meal!