UPDATE (5/11/13):
The Cafe part of Blue Hill Lodge & Cafe still cannot get food out of the kitchen in a reasonable time. I brought my mother and father to grab a quick meal. My Mother and I ordered deli sandwiches for dinner and my father ordered fish & chips. There were two other groups there (two groups of 3). It took over 45 minutes from the time we ordered to the time we received our food this is dinner on a Saturday night (Gordon Ramsey would disapprove). We could have drove into Liberty and ordered food and got it in the same amount of time and honestly in the future that is what we will do. I both live and work very closely to this establishment and will be directing my guests to better establishments that are a bit further away. Very disappointing. The sandwiches were good, the fish and chips were triangle fish sticks (way over charged for them as well), again, very disappointing.
This place is great. Â Every time my friends and I go here the lady that runs the place hooks us up with excellent imported Russian beer they always have stocked (check the fridge) and free tastes of imported sausage. Â As reflected in the other reviews, the deli menu is also pretty strong for being way up in God's country (i.e., Denning and Claryville). Â This is best (only) place to stop on your way back from a hike in Slide Mountain Wilderness or a ski at Bellayre. Â However, the best experience is to sit out on the picnic table on a warm summer day with a cold beer and take in the surrounding mountains.
Review Source: