Bon Rico Supper Club

Thank you fellow yelpers for sending me here.  Me and my buddies were on our way back to Park city from a fishing trip on the Green river when we did a search for a good steak and this place came up.  Odd name, odd decor, great service and quality food.  Do heed the warnings on the steak sizes.  The petite is more than enough for the average person. If you are passing through Evanston, stop in, you will be glad you did.

I never would have even walked into this place had I not seen it on Yelp and read the other reviews. From the outside it really doesn't look that great; it looks pretty crummy from the inside too now that I mention it.  And a name like "Bon Rico Supper Club?" Kind of weird.

Once I started eating the different courses of the meal I was fairly impressed however. It started with a plate of cold veggies; asparagus, carrots, radishes, celery, olives, etc. Then there was the French Onion soup, followed by the salad and the fresh bread. All of it was decently good. When my ribeye arrived, I really wished I had taken the advice of the other Yelpers on here and ordered the Petite ribeye. I ordered the regular one and it was literally two inches thick! Huge! I have a big appetite and still couldn't eat more than half of it!  

While the atmosphere wasn't the greatest, the service was good and the food was better than I expected. I definitely recommend this place, and will eat here again next time I am in Evanston!  (Be aware, they close at 8PM every night apparently.)

Just remember: ORDER THE PETITE STEAK! :)

Great juicy steak and good deal for your money.  I heard about this place from the local people while in town for business.  The outside doesn't look appealing but great steak.  French onion soup was ok.  Don't use the restroom if you don't really need to go.