Lovin' the Pub at Frog Hollow. Like the other reviewer said this is DEFINITELY Middletown's best kept secret. On a nice quiet night this is the place to eat. I would not go there on a holiday! This is a small place! GREAT specials though. My husband had wings and soft pretzels as an appetizer and they were fabulous. I had salmon for dinner - VERY well seasoned. With two appetizers, two entrees and one dessert (plus drinks) we spent $40 before tip. I felt like this is the best food I've had since I've moved to Middletown. This is a child friendly restaurant as well and if its a nice night I recommend sitting outside. Great staff!
I wouldn't be so harsh about consistency if you go on a holiday - never a good time to go to any restaurant for the best service and food.