I really love my annual summer and fall visits to Saugatuck for the scenery, shopping and the friendly people. After dining at a few of the other local eateries my expectations are pretty low when it comes to mind-blowing meals, but Mermaid is my favorite choice. It isn't fancy fare, but the have the sandwich/wrap/burger thing down! My favorite is the turkey sundried tomato wrap (side note: it's huge! Way too much food for a standard lunch) with sweet potato fries. I had a hard time deciding whose fries were better: The Mermaid or Coral Gables (not a fan of CG but the fries are legendary) and I think The Mermaid's nudged its way to the top spot today.
The interior is a little dim and outdated; the outside dining area is the way to go. Gorgeous view of the marina and million dollar yachts combined with plenty of sunshine! No complaints on the staff either - waiters are efficient and do an above average job.
Bottom line? Come with a laid back attitude, go with a sandwich (not a steak) and enjoy the water!