My friend and I were in New Milford on a quick middle-of-the-week vacation. We happened to find this pub by sheer luck - as it's a little off the main shopping road. We stopped in for a happy hour and loved it so much we went back the next night (Wednesdays are open mic night - so fun!). I was a little disappointed they didn't have Harp (what???) but the bartender offered a great alternative. They were training a new waitress, and that seemed to be a disaster (she would forget who ordered the food and she'd forget to bring drinks), but we didn't experience any problems.
My friend and I looked at each other and said, "This feels like home. " We may like our Irish pubs a bit too much, but this was a great fun, casual, and welcoming bar.
Review Source: