Stalnaker's Restaurant

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  Just sad. The food is reheated, the building is in complete disrepair. I remember the wonderful food, but those days are gone.
  At least the service is sweet, polite and refreshing.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 08.14.13 James M.

  • Report
• 0

  This place is wayyy in Tioga and looks like an OLD SHACK OR FACTORY!!! It's suppose to be a "buffet" but it's NOT, because the staff prepares your plate for you...you only tell them what you want on it. This place is ALWAYS crowded and really needs a good cleaning. The staff are extremely nice, but look like they just butchered a cow outside. Also, the sitting area looks like a school cafateria (weird). The food is mostly seafood, but the taste is "very average" and not to mention, EXTREMELY Expensive ($22.00 for the regular buffet). I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here!!!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 05.19.10 Yelp's King Of…

  • Report
• 0

  Well I've been here several times, but I go back just to see if it hasn't gotten better. I went tonight 11/10/09 and I remember why it took me so long to return. The boiled shrimp were huge but way over cooked and I don't know what they boil them  in but it is not Zateran's seasonings, the catfish was overcooked (hard as a rock) What they need to is fry the shrimp they boil instead of the little popcorn shrimp on the bar, now that would be good. I think the boiled corn was left over from yesterday. I must not be the only one that has gotten enough of this place because there was about three maybe four couples eating....It's the Pits

  Review Source:

  Posted on 11.10.09 John L.

  • Report