Went to Toby's last weekend over the July 4th holiday with seven friends. The mussels are the best I've ever had. Hands down, to die for! They had a special on the menu for a crab bisque that was out of this world. We ordered a fried seafood platter that was not very good, hence 4 stars.
However, the bar, wait staff, atmosphere and mussels were outstanding! Definitely worth it and will be back!
Best and freshest mussels around, hands down, and my fiancé and I have tried dozens of restaurants, from fancy to casual in the P.N.W. Great taxidermy collection (and view) to boot!
Post-meal amendment: still 5-stars mussels, but I have to drop the rating on account of a horrible bison-burger and passive-aggressive service. Come here for afternoon mussels and drinks, anything else is uncertain.