Allegany Grill

Classic 1950s roadhouse outside & in, so most people get scared & drive right by. Big mistake! Not much to look at, but the food is fresh, the prices are fair, and the steaks are grilled just the way grandpa used to make 'em, without shying away from seasoning them nicely.
I've had far worse soups & salads at much fancier places, too, and they weren't included like they are here. Well worth stopping in.

My in-laws took me and husband out for dinner here on Saturday night.  They live way out in the boonies and this is one of the few places to eat out.
The lot is dirt and gravel and all the spaces directly in front of the restaurant were filled so we parked in the side lot, and were greeted by a trio of feral cats.  Very country.
Inside it is very cute and the ambience is very homey.  There is a hand painted trim of flowers painted on the walls and seating for about 20 or so patrons at a time.
All in all, it was very relaxed and the food is good.  
The menu has quite a variety.  I had Shrimp Scampi over fettucini, the others ordered a Haddock fish fry, baked Haddock and a beautiful steak.  Each dinner comes with the complimentary soup and salad bar.  I had an excellent mushroom soup, but the salad bar was only so-so.  The fish fry was great with super crispy french fries and by all accounts, everything else was good too.  My only complaint was that my pasta was a little mushy for my taste.
The waitress was great, friendly and prompt.
It's a cute place to eat if you're out that way, but nothing spectacular.