We tried Colony Grill a few weeks after it opened and thought it was pretty good! Â We went in knowing that they only serve pizza, so we weren't disappointed on that point, but it is pretty misleading to call it a "grill" now that other reviewers bring it up. Â
Anyhow, the interior looks great, smells nice and new (love that!), and we thought the pizza was very good (even though it isn't our favorite 'type' of pizza: super thin, no crust - but this we also knew ahead of time). Â We went at lunch when it was pretty quiet inside so it was nice. Â We plan to go back sometime at night so hopefully it's just as good! Â
The only real complaint I have is that they use canned mushrooms - c'mon guys, stock some fresh ones! :)