Humble Pie of Putnam County

What a pizza! Best in Putnam County by a LONG shot! The dough is amazing. The topping choices will keep you wanting to try different combinations each visit!

May I suggest the pepperoni, Chicago sausage, bacon, green olives, green peppers, and almond slivers. WOWOW!  

They function out of a building smaller than most garages, so its carry-out and delivery only. You walk in to get your pizza and you are greeted by a friendly staff and the smell of Heaven.

If they had a place to sit down, and had a beer license, I would be there every Friday or Saturday, because what goes best with pizza? Beer!

They also have amazing breadsticks!!!The cinnamon breadsticks are so melt in your mouth amazing!

Go there. Right now. Go. Except on Sundays, they are closed. Pizza this amazing needs a day of rest!

Best pizza I have had in a long long time.  I tried the hand tossed cheese, and loved everything about it, and will be going back.  The dough had a good flavor to it, good thickness, the sauce was great, and the cheese was great.

Humble Pie has become one of our favorites in Greencastle.  One of the newest locally owned restaurants and among the best.  Besides all the typical pizza toppings a person would normally find, Humble Pie has interesting selection of non-typical topping such as artichoke hearts, roasted almonds, fresh basil, capers, and several cheeses e.g. Asiago, blue cheese, feta, goat cheese, etc.  Also all of their pizzas and sandwiches are homemade.  Check them out.