Jake Starr Restaurant And Bar

Grata breakfast, pro only the best on town. Dinner was tasty and our server was excellent. Highly recomend

Ate lunch here recently.  Overpriced and mediocre food.  The bread on my panini was stale.  There is no excuse for serving stale bread.  The drinks and tap beers are the bright spot for this place.  The food is not good.  Do not expect too much from this place.  I would not recommend it.

I had a pretty horrible experience at Jake Starr Cafe.The burger which I ordered medium rare, came back burned to a crisp on both sides, it tasted terrible and looked like they either tried scraping off the burnt part of the patty or it was stuck to their grill. If you can imagine all the food they cook on a grill then have a burger sit and burn on it that's what I had to taste with each bite. The burnt burger along with everything that was previous cooked on the grill.

The burger was also smaller than the bun, considerably smaller. The piece of lettuce I got was almost as big as the plate. I basically had tare the lettuce with my hand, rip away the excess bun and re-build the burger. I eat at a lot of local restaurants around Port Jefferson, from Billies, Toast, Lake Grove Diner, all have much better burgers than Jake Starr. I don't know how a chef would let a burger burnt like that leave their kitchen. I will not be going back. Their servers can also use some better training.