Three stars is all I'm giving Keeley's, despite being a loyal customer.
"Why?" you ask.
Well let's start off with the positives.
Keeley's has an outstanding deck great for a summer-time dinner or drinks, if you want, in the great outdoors. During the summer months Keeley's has a good vibe.
No for the the bad and the ugly.
Unfortunately the deck get's packed and the people who get there early, stay there late. So if you show up at 7:00 on a Saturday, don't get your hopes up that you're getting a table or even a bar stool. The great Yogi Berra said it best when he uttered the phrase, "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded."
Furthermore, although open all year long, Keeley's is strictly a summer-time bar and restaurant. Yes, once the temperature gets below 75 it's a whole new ballgame.
The inside is dark, sometimes loud from the jukebox and the summer favorites on the menu just don't have the same feel in the fall and winter.