I was there on a weekday looking for a dive, and McCarthy's definitely filled the requirements. The crowd seemed a little shady, but they all kept to their own group of people. I was glad to find a place with pool tables, multiple dart boards, and a decent jukebox... Oh, and they also serve reasonably priced beer; not sure about the mixer prices tho. They have a nice "tiki" bar out back as well which could use some work. Overall tho, it's just a run down bar to go and kick it.
Review Source: