Medley's Cafe

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  I have to admit, right up front, that when Medleys Cafe was in Corning NY, I worked there for Mary.  She drove to Corning every day from Prattsburg to offer her super homemade foods, vegetarian in the beginning.  Somewhere along the line, after I left, she started including meat.  It wasn't about vegetarianism so much as it was about good, whole foods and knowing what goes into them.  The bread is made on site, salad dressings, tabouli, and everything else.  Today was my first visit to the Prattsburg location and it was like walking into history... the same mixed selection of chairs, tables and decorations.  Lots of live plants and art (for sale) on the walls.  
  
  You order lunch at the counter and menus are in large print on boards on the walls.  Most of the same items that I and others loved in Corning.  Mary has just started doing catering again, too.  What would I recommend?  Well, for one thing, call ahead and ask if she's made Veggie Cheese Rollups.  They are the best!  Homemade soups of the day and homemade quiche of the day.  I had Potato Corn Chowder today "just like Mom used to make"!  Unpeeled, diced potatoes, corn, parsley, lots of freshly ground pepper, chicken broth (I think).  It was so-o good.
  
  Dinners vary each night, and she comes up with some great ones.  Just to give you an idea, here's what she recently posted on Facebook:  "Steak Salad - 5 oz. sirloin over greens with Bleu, mandarine orange, red onion, Seared Mahi Mahi with roasted pepper and cilantro pesto, Creekstone Filet with Bacon Wrapped Shrimp, Roasted Pork Loin with Apple Chutney, and our ever-so-famous creme brulee".  Busy dinner trade with customers coming from Bath, Hammondsport, Naples, etc.  Evening entertainment varies.  Check her Medleys Cafe Facebook page.
  
  I could go on and on, but you need to try it for yourself.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 05.23.13 Kathleen R.

  • Report
• 0

  I'm grading on a slight curve here 'cause it's in smack the middle of one sorry-looking downtown. Never sat down for a meal but we always grab sandwiches for the ride when heading back downstate and I am always impressed with the offerings. They make their own bread and take a lot of care and I can't wait to try them for dinner.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 11.05.12 Paul K.

  • Report
• 0

  My husband & I have been here for dinner quite a few times and have always had a great meal.  The food is tasty, fresh and reasonably priced.  I love the way Mary takes an ordinary dish and makes it unique.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 11.01.12 Mary W.

  • Report
• 0

  Mary's Medley's Cafe is a treasure in the Finger Lakes!! Deeeeeelishious meals made from fresh veggies and meats that make you start thinking of your Friday night meal on Monday. One of the BEST kept secrets in our area. If you haven't tried Medley's, you don't know what you are missing!!!

  Review Source:

  Posted on 11.01.12 Michael G.

  • Report
• 0

  I love Medley's. Friendly, intimate atmosphere. The new art installations each month are fun. I think of this place as Ithaca/Burlington style food with a fresh focus (though it's not vegetarian, so meat lovers, don't worry). Lunch is a great value and the soups are simply outstanding. Dinner is more elaborate and a real treat, especially with the winter entertainment bookings.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 11.01.12 Blake K.

  • Report
• 0

  This has to be the BEST restaurant in Prattsburgh.  Delicious food and all tasty and different.  The specials change often and the desserts are all amazing...homemade food at its best.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 09.29.12 Donna F.

  • Report