Ok, if you walk in you may think I"m crazy.  Crazy like a fox!  This place is kinda divey and Margaretville is not exactly a haven for foodies.  I was nervous about going there as I read some other reviews while outside the place but decided to give it a shot.  Though I can't remember the name I had a hefty bacon cheesburger  with bbq sauce (it's one of their main options) and ordered it well-done.  It's not cheap and it took awhile to get it together but it was DAMN GOOD (except the fries were so-so, but that's ok).  Also, they get 5 Stars for their beers on tap including Mother's Milk and some others that are brewed in Kingston.  I can't vouch for anything else but if you stick with what I had you can't go wrong.
Review Source:Had lunch on the Tiki deck. Very good tuna tartar, fried calamari and buffalo wings (baked, not fried).
The food was generously portioned and tasty. The calamari were a bit overcooked but the wings were huge, like they came from "Chickenzilla".
Good Margaritas and cold beers. Charming waitress too.