Place gets it's rating on atmosphere alone. Not only is it in a great location (a bit far out in the the woods albeit), but the environment is great. Good beer selection, and and an even more eclectic selection for dinner (I had alligator!). Cooking the food yourself is entertaining, could see how it could get old and lose its novelty, but it's certainly worth the visit if you haven't been before.
Review Source:This place is  in the middle of nowhere. We were invited by another couple who lived much closer than us. All your food is purchased inside raw and you bring it out to the grills to cook yourself. At the grills they have all the seasonings and sauces you would need along with an employee to help if you need it. We were lucky to get a nice table by the creek. The servers are basically there to get you cocktails, and OH did we drink them up.
 Overall we had a great time, just not sure it was worth the drive.