Blackfish

Great food, ambience and service.  The cuisine is great.  Only drawback were the mosquitoes.  My wife and I were bitten approximately 5  times each. The waitress told us the restaurant was built near a swamp so figures.  Wear bug repellent, preferrably with Deet.

Best bartender on the Cape. If you go sit at the bar when Mariah is working. She makes incredible fancy cocktails and her menu recommendations are on point. Also the garlic bread and hummus is incredible and she kept it coming.

We've been to Blackfish thrice -- once last year and twice over the past week. Everytime we go, we are amazed. We summer on the Lower Cape every year and, hands down, Blackfish is the best restaurant on the Cape (sorry, PB). The fresh tuna bolognese are what we keep coming back for. Equally delicious are the rabbit ragu and the butter lobster gnocchi. We recommend the panna cotta for dessert.

Writing this good review pains me because I know it will increase the number of competition for tables here. But, the word is out already and it's a shame to keep this as a hidden gem!