Holy freaking cheesy!!!! Â I think the sauce was good, and I'm pretty sure that the crust was as well, but I can't be sure as all I could taste was the freaking CHEESE!!! Â We ordered take-out, so I didn't get a chance to experience the restaurant, the service, or the neighboring Crown Brewery, but I will say that they were extremely nice over the phone placing the order.
Did I mention that the pizza was really cheesy???
If I could I would give this place NO stars I would....but you have to enter in a star to write a review!!!  We had the most awful expericnce here I've ever had at any restaurant ever!!!  We placed an order that included both appitizers and pizza's and a burger and fries for a 2 year old boy....we waited and waited and watied FINALLY the food came out all at once appitzers and pizza's NO burger... try keeping a 2 year old hungry boy quiet while he waited for his food...we were told the burger is coming right out...well 20 minutes later the burger did come out when the adults were almost finished eating!!  I asked to see a mangager and a young in-experienced cocky guy came over (manager's son) and made it sound like it was OUR fault that the kitchen had NO clue what they were doing!!  All I really wanted was the burger taken off of our check...we were told that they do NOT comp anything EVER!!  I asked to speak to the cocky kids father who is also a manager and he was NO help either...I truly don't understand how a place has NO people skills yet they cater to the public...they must not know that customers pay the bills and keep the place open.  I may be a small fish but I'm going to spread the word around that they truly disrespect  their customers and from what I've read their employee's as well!!!  My father had a restaurant right next door to that place for over 26 years and he NEVER treated his customers with disrespect...I can't imagine making a customer feel like it was their fault the kitchen had NO timing on food.  I wish that place luck they are gonna need it with thier people skills or lack there of!!!
Review Source:Definitely my favorite pizza in NW Indiana. Very good crust on their deep dish, the sauce tastes great and the pizzas are very cheasy. Someone had mentioned in their review that it's greasy. I have definitely had greasier pizza, but it's definitely not pizza that you would eat while on a diet. I have always done delivery, but since it is attached to crown brewery now I have been meaning to eat in. Love their pizza tho!
Review Source:This place just feels like home. The service is good, the food is excellent and it's attatched to "Crown Brewery", which  won many awards for their brews. Visit them Tues. & Thurs. for great specials.  If this is the  first time going there, don't be "turned off" by the smaller scaled building, there's a lot of room inside and out!!!!
Review Source:Not my favorite pizza place, but for some reason its around me more than I'd prefer. Â Carriage Court is a convenient local carry out pizza place, which is probably why people order it frequently.
Carriage Court is greasy and the cheese doesn't taste very good. Â Sauce and crust are decent. Â
There are just so many other pizza places to order from, Carriage Court would not even make my top 5.
So if you are in NW Indiana and want to order pizza, I would not suggest ordering Carriage Court.
On the other hand, some people favor here over other places. Â It's just personal opinion.