That was the worst burger I have ever eaten! First the guy bringing our two burgers asked if we had the turkey burger. I said I ordered the malibu. He said, yeah malibu and left it in front of me. I could clearly see that it was a white meat and not beef. Our waitress saw and said that wasn't the malibu and took it away. She re-appeared 30 seconds later with a malibu burger. I thought, that was fast. Here is where it goes downhill. I took a bite. The patty was way over cooked. The menu says all the burgers are cooked medium pink throughout and the waitress confirmed that medium was okay when I ordered. Mine was ash grey throughout. It tasted as if it had been cooked a few days ago and either frozen or refridgerated and reheated in a microwave. I grill burgers. I eat burgers from In-N-Out and occasionally from Carl's or Wendy's. There is no way that island's burger was cooked the same day I ate it. Â I guess they thought I wouldn't notice? For 10.50 it should at least taste as good as a 3 dollar burger. Save your money. I will never go back
Review Source: