I was meeting friends on a Saturday evening for music, dancing and dinner.  I ordered the  BBQ ribs.  The waitress said she served lots of them and had never had a complaint.  The ribs were a small half rack with BBQ sauce poured down the middle of the meat.  The sauce tasted like Old Bay and I am not a fan of Old Bay.  The potato was barely done but the salad was nice.  My friend sampled the BBQ sauce, and she also could taste Old Bay in the BBQ sauce.  I returned the ribs, since they were not to my liking, and I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich.  The chicken was a small piece, but it was cooked correctly and did not taste like Old Bay.
The Tiki Bar where the band played was very warm and the band was SO LOUD that you could not ever scream and hear the person next to you or the waitress when she came to the table. Â The band did turn it down a bit, but it was still to loud. Â The dance floor was wood, but it was very sticky. Â Not a good floor if you love to dance. Â
I rate the service with 5 stars! Â Our server was very pleasant and accommodating and took good care of our table. Â The food was not the best, but not the worst. Â I have never tasted Old Bay BBQ ribs and was certainly NOT impressed with their BBQ that tasted like Old Bay. Â It is really to bad since the meat was tender. Â The chicken was OK, but not the best. Â I have had much better bar food and this was a restaurant. Â I expected it to be much better. Â Sadly, I don't believe this will be a place that I frequent. Â It is to bad since it is very close to where I live.
I just got off the phone with Tony Ashe, Owner and General Manager of The Mallet. Â He apologized the mess we all had to experience last Saturday night at the restaurant, and attributed the problem to a much larger than normal crowd that night. Â He said their previous record was just over 500 diners on a Saturday night; on January 28, 2012 they had over 700. Â He said they are taking two important actions to prevent a recurrance: Â capacity control so they max out at less than 600 diners on a given evening, and (more importantly), a simplification of the downstairs menu. Â Both should help, I believe. Â He also offered to send a $50 certificate, but I suggested he give it to our beleagered waitress that evening. Â He told me that at the end of that night, he gave the wait staff that had troubled tables a $25 bonus, but that he would tell our waitress that we made the offer. Â I think we'll give them another chance, BUT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE WEEK!!!!
Review Source:Upon arrival there are no clues to what the upper and lower level dining areas are about, you have to wander to figure it out. Crabs are advertised as you enter the lower level bar area but you can't eat them there, even our waitress did not know that, someone else had to tell her. A couple outside eating had told us prior that the place was crazy and no one seemed to know what was going on. So after being moved from the bar to the unknown raw bar area we ordered crab dip and a dozen large crabs. The crab dip was runny and tasted like clam chowder, the bread was small and over toasted. When our waitress asked how the dip was we informed her and she said she that she thought it was great, we told her that you couldn't even taste crab and she said this was the new italian chefs version (if it ain't broke why fix it, go to Silver Spring Inn for the real thing). So then the medium crabs arrived, we were still charged for large, they were short on spices, has a hint of vinegar and old bay. Maryland crabs should be steamed with salt, dry mustard, old bay, vinegar and beer. Would appear that this is the new italain chefs version. The pricing is too high for what is given in return. So a return trip is unlikely, be warned!
Review Source: