I live literally a couple doors down from Manhattan, have ordered on a regular basis, and have always had great service and product. Â However, my last order really sucked. Â The pizza was cold, the crust was at least 1/3 of the entire pie, I ordered extra sauce (which wasn't added), and the pizza was burnt.
I called again tonight to hopefully have them redeem themselves (I even mentioned how awful my previous order was). Â The guy on the phone gave me $5 off (totally unexpected, but quite nice). Â I proceeded to order my usual -- x-sauce, pepperoni, banana peppers (sometimes a mix with jalapenos). Â
I was really surprised, especially after having just complained and even receiving a discount -- my pizza arrived ICE cold. Â WTF I live a couple doors down, and can't get a hot pizza? Â Plus, I counted literally 8 slices of banana pepper and 7 pepperoni. Â Really how incredibly chintzy is that ? Â Without the discount that small pizza would have been $12. Â Plus, it was also really well done, and was black in spots. Â
I don't know what to say, other than I will not be ordering from them in the future. Â There are a TON of pizza places in Burlington, why should I give my hard earned money for a crappy product?
Manhattan Pizza & Pub has a great ambience. Â It is hip/grungy, with talkative bouncers and a fair selection of beers. There are some weird characters milling around there on the weekends, along with totally average students and older people. Â I think a 6:1 ratio of the normal to the odd is a perfect mix for a bar. Â This hilarious dude almost got into a fight next to our table and since a very polite/observant man warned us about the brewing trouble, we were able to turn around and enjoy it rather than get accidentally knocked over while he flailed.
I will say that one particular night they had put up a lot of beers on their chalk board that weren't available on tap yet, so every time we would try to order beers (that were on the menu!) they would cut us off and say they weren't actually available until the next night. Â Why did you write them on the board then??
I only came in here for a drink with a group of 3 others. It was during Mardi Gras so it was crowded. Probably a different scene on a regular day, but the bartender was good and the drinks weren't expensive so, not so bad considering they were packed to their maximum capacity. The pizza looked good - would've liked to have tried it.
Review Source:Wow! I was completely taken by surprise at Manhattan Pizza & Pub. Hubby and I were in Burlington, VT for the weekend and really wanted to grab a slice of pizza. Being short on time and hungry, we stopped into Manhattan Pizza. We ordered their house specialty, the Manhattan. It was absolutely fabulous! The crust was just right, the vegetables firm and tasty and the meat was fresh! It was truly scrumptious!
Another wonderful surprise was the live band that began playing around 9. The sounds of The Bumping Jones were awesome and made our night truly awesome!
I just completed a week long stay in Burlington and this was by far my favorite place in the city. We walked in during Philly Friday because the chalkboard outside caught our eye. You walk in, grab a menu, order at the bar and have a seat.
They have basic bar food and I ordered the Philly. The man and woman working were extremely friendly and gave us as much time as we needed. The decor was mainly bar signs, no real flow. While I was waiting for my food I was able to watch a baseball game and listen to Johnny Cash playing int he BACKGROUND. The music was at the perfect level so I could still carry on conversation and hear myself think.
The Philly was excellent. The bread was very good and the flavor was great. Like I said, I was in Burlington for a week and this is the only place where the food, drinks, prices, and service were beyond average.
In Vermont for a wedding and having missed the end of Pride, my travel buddy and I found ourselves roaming aimlessly through Burlington at night, tryin' to find some action.
...And then we heard metal.
Pints of hard liquor, cheap beer, and Lord Silky. A totally strange crowd. Baseball on the TVs. This is where it's at, man.
Horrible food. Terrible service. Undrinkable drinks. Three strikes and you're OUT, in my mind. I realized this far too late. I stubbled on this spot coming in late one Sunday night from the BEST (west) coast ... Looking for a bite to eat in this small town at 10:30 PM. Â Not good.
A college dive bar, for sure. You'd have to be stoned, drunk AND starving to eat the stuff coming out of that kitchen. Pretty pitiful, really.
The beer flows freely and they have a few hard-to-find seasonal beers like Shipyard's Pumpkinhead on tap. The pizza toppings are fresh and the pastas are customizable, but why are they wasting these fresh, delicious toppings on school cafeteria-quality pizza? Definitely a place to drink first, eat later until their pizza shapes up.
Review Source:Amidst the noise of college coeds, hippies playing pool, and me playing the original Mortal Kombat on arcade, was a reallllllly good burger for $5 and the worst pizza I have ever eaten for $2. Â Seriously. Â This was the worst pizza I have ever eaten; in fact, I might chalk it up as the only pizza I have ever not eaten- it was just uneatable. Â The worst. Â However, we had a lot of fun here.
Quick aside, I totally blew up this kids spot and probably made sure he didn't get laid that night. Â He was at the ATM and it wasn't giving him money- there was a girl with him and they needed it for the cab. Â He goes, "it's broken, it's not giving me money."
It gave me money. Â It gave my girlfriend money. Â Clearly it's one of those ATMs that requires you to have money in your bank account for it to actually disperse cash for you. Â Perhaps if he had spent less money getting this girl wasted enough to go home with him, he could have had the money needed to get home. Â But probably, had he not had the girl wasted, there would have been no reason to leave. Â It's a real catch 22.
I also may have prevented an unplanned pregnancy that night. Â So I guess that's another point for me.
I love the footlong Philly Cheesesteak Fridays for $5 promotion. The sub is huge and they don't skimp out on the meat or cheese. For that kind it value, it sure does beat your local Subway or Quiznos.
On the other hand their pizzas didn't measure up. I have a deep passion for New York style pizza and I have had my fair share. They got the thinness right, but something just didn't taste right. I tried one with meatballs and another with just mushrooms. The one topped with meatballs had a strange gamey taste. The mushrooms tasted good, but the sauce didn't taste familiar. The crust was a bit too doughy for my liking. Other than that, the prices are fair and you'll at least get a better pizza than Domino's.
My favorite traditional pizza in Burlington. Funnily enough, it reminds me of the great pizza I've had in Boston, not Manhattan. They really do put out some great work on those pies.
The all you can eat pizza/wings night are a great deal. I love that they'll make any type of slice you want. Sometimes, I would go in and want eggplant, sometimes olive. Why choose? Get both! Without ordering a whole pizza.
The atmosphere in Manhattan is so casual and down to earth, it's always a nice place to just go an relax with friends while having a beer and eating delicious pizza. I also highly recommend their cheesy garlic bread. For real, guys, it's outstanding. It also really didn't hurt that I had a crush on the bartender here, haha. What can I say? There's so much to recommend about this place, including the servers!
Yuk! This place is pretty terrible. I'm always bewildered that it seems to attract a huge crowd every weekend. It is pretty cheap, but you get what you pay for. A full bar with cheap drink specials might be the reason obnoxious bros flock here to get their "Natty On." If you're going to call yourself "Manhattan Pizza" then your product should at least be reminiscent of some of NYC's finest. (Ray's) Sadly the pizza here is about the farthest thing from it...
Review Source:One of the nastiest places to eat in Burlington, hands down..!! The food is terrible, overpriced (like every place in Btown VT), and the place is usually filthy from the tables down. I've never been in a place w/ so many tables in need of bus service, or even a general wipe down. The place has a funky  odor to match the dirty decor and terrible eating tables. I ate there again a few days back, thinking something may have changed, but after 2 bites of my sub (which I HAD to eat elsewhere because of the P-Funk in that place) the 1st homeless person to ask me for food got the "prized" sandwich. UNLESS you're STARVING and the FOOD is FREE, there's no reason to waste your time in that place. It's really gone down hill in the last few years...
Review Source:First of all, the all-you-can eat pizza and wings are now $10.95, which isn't that much of a great deal, unless you're going to really pig out.
The service here was horrendous - it was a Saturday afternoon, and while it was busy in Burlington, it isn't like it was that busy in the restaurant, but the red-headed stoner dude behind the counter was clearly flustered and couldn't handle more than one simple task at a time. Â Watching him do his job was like watching paint dry, but more frustrating. Â
Out of the 12-15 taps of interesting beer that they had there, at least 6 of them were out of order, and half of the remaining ones were pushing out warm, flat beer. Â HELLO! This is Burlington - you gotta serve good beer!!! Â
As for the food, the pizza was OK - kinda flavorless until you added your own garlic, italian seasonings, pepper flakes and cheese. Â
Oh, and it is kinda dingy. Â This could be an awesome little place - great location, nice menu, lots of good beers and big screen TVs, but the execution just sucks.
Manhattan Pizza saved me from many a hangover in college. Stumbling in right after the bars closed (or a few minutes before to save yourself the line) to order a few slices. Pizza never tasted so good. And I never felt so decent the next day even after a 12 hour drinkfest.
Definitely go for the $8 all-you-can-eat pizza and wings night.
In the summer, they open the place up. Nice place to grab a quick slice before heading downtown.
:::Drool:::    Manhattans    :::Drool:::
All-you-can-eat wings and pizza for only $8? Â COUNT ME IN!
Unlimited soda for $1 more? Â YES PLEASE!
Trough after trough after trough of unlimited wings pretty much defined my Tuesday nights in 2003-2004. (Shout out to Phil K., one of my partners in crime!) Â
Mild, Hot, Superhot, Honey BBQ, Regular BBQ, Teriyaki, carrot and celery sticks, paper plates, napkins. Â TONS of napkins. Covered in wing juice and sauce. Â The glory of our victory was determined by the size of the boneyard we constructed by the end of the hour. Â And if per chance we ate the wings faster than the Manhattans staff could replenish the supply, the pizza stood as a formidable distraction. Â The pizza! Oh the pizza... I just got chills thinking about that scrumptious pizza.
DISCLAIMER: No chickens were harmed in the making of this review. We just ate their wings. Â Thousands of them. Â For $8.
The 5 best restaurants in the 2015 Denver Restaurant Week
3,611 Views | Category: Denver
The complete list of 2015 Denver Restaurant Week businesses
1,971 Views | Category: Denver
The tourists' guide to Portillos: 5 must have dishes
3,316 Views | Category: Chicago
Pho = Pronounced "fuh" not "foe" for pho-king sake
2,913 Views | Category: Denver
Indulgery selected to exhibit at Collision Conference
2,986 Views | Category: Press Releases
Not Logged In
BUSINESSES
Local Businesses
Near Me
My Favorites
SOCIAL
Blog & News
MY ACCOUNT
Login
Register
Contact Us
Add Your Business
