McSalty's Pizza Cafe

Pathetic - At the McSalty's on Sunshine - We were served brown lettuce on the salads we ordered.  It took nearly an hour to get the 2 pizzas to the table and the excuse was they were busy.  But we were the only ones there ?   No wonder the parking lot is always empty.   Plus way over priced too !   - Ick - will not be back

Had a Bear Pie. Tasted a bit off but mostly ok. They were out of smoothies; have no flavored lemonade (except pink) but they should. Server had to ask me multiple times what soda I was having, only 3 ppl at my table. They enjoyed their dinners. Floors needed vacuumed.  Server walked by 3 times after I told him I wanted a refill and he had taken my glass before he brought my refill and even the I had to remind him. I've had better food here many times before. They weren't busy: 2 tables, maybe 3. At about 715 pm on a Tuesday so service and the food should have been much better. Likely to return our next time in the area for another chance.

I've heard so many people say to go to McSalty's. I've lived here for 8 years, but I'm from New York, so I'm a very bad pizza snob. People said: "this place will shut you up!". Well, it didn't.

Compared to New York pizza: 0 stars. Awful. So if you are visiting from such places, avoid.  

Compared to Springfield area pizza: 3 stars. Nothing special. If you are a local, it's probably okay.

The dough is under-proofed, leading to a cracker like crust. For a place in business so long, you'd think they wouldn't under-proof. They also use a wheat flour, which is interesting in theory but it was unremarkable in taste. The sauce was virtually non-existent - I could barely taste any. Was there any on the pizza? If there was, they used an eye-dropper to put it on. They put cheddar on the pizza (good lord) and the other cheeses were sub-standard and cheap. The mushrooms were clearly out of a can (seriously?).  The meat (sausage and beef, I think) were boring and lacked in much taste.

Essentially, it was like a decent frozen food section pizza. Not impressed.  You might also be interested to know that given the sub-standard pizza, it's also very overpriced. Very.

Save your money - if this is the kind of pizza you like, go to Pizza Hut or some other chain. You'll get the same thing for less.